Memorial on Behalf of Respondent for 6th National Moot Court Competition, 2016, Schemes and Mind Maps of Law

Download Memorial on Behalf of Respondent for 6th National Moot Court Competition, 2016 and more Schemes and Mind Maps Law in PDF only on Docsity!

6TH NATIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 20166TH NATIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 2016

TeTeamam CodeCode:: BeforeBefore THE HON’BLE SUPREME COURT OF EUREKATHE HON’BLE SUPREME COURT OF EUREKA SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (Cri.) NO. .. !OF "#$%SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (Cri.) NO. .. !OF "#$% IN THE MATIN THE MATTER OFTER OF &AV&AVI&I& '' ANR.ANR. ...................................................................................................................................................AP.....................APPELLANTSPELLANTS

..

STASTATE OF ATE OF AL&HIEML&HIEM ...RESPON&...RESPON&ENTENT

COUNSELS APPEARIN* ON BEHALF OF THE RESPON&ANT STATE OF AL&HIEMCOUNSELS APPEARIN* ON BEHALF OF THE RESPON&ANT STATE OF AL&HIEM

6TH NATIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 20166TH NATIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 2016

TABLE OF CONTENTTABLE OF CONTENT

IN&E+ OF AUTHORITIES .VIN&E+ OF AUTHORITIES .V

STASTATEMENT OF ,URIS&ICTITEMENT OF ,URIS&ICTION.VIIION.VIII

STASTATEMENT OF FACTS .........TEMENT OF FACTS ...........I+..I+

ISSUES RAISE& ...... +IISSUES RAISE& ...... +I

SUMMAR- OF ARUMENTS ....+IISUMMAR- OF ARUMENTS ....+II

ARUMENTS A&VANCE& ....+IVARUMENTS A&VANCE& ....+IV

PRA-ER...++I+PRA-ER...++I+

$.$. Te CaTe Ca/e o0 1e/e o0 1e A2A22e33a2e33a41 No. $ (&41 No. $ (&aid) iaid) i/ 4o1 3ia5/ 4o1 3ia53e 1o 5e re3e 1o 5e rema4dema4ded 5a67 1o 1d 5a67 1o 1ee ,8e4i3e Board Commi11ee ........+IV,8e4i3e Board Commi11ee ........+IV Premises –Premises – 1.1 Inquiry before the Juvenile Board Committee1.1 Inquiry before the Juvenile Board Committee 1.2 The trial in the Session Court1.2 The trial in the Session Court 1.3 Petition in the i!h Court1.3 Petition in the i!h Court ".". TTee P8P84i4i//meme 4141 o0o0 11ee AA 2222 e3e33a3a 4141 NoNo.. "" (U(U 9898 aa 33 P8P8roroii1)1) //o8o83d3d 4o4o 11 5e5e /8/2e4ded ....++I/8/2e4ded ....++I LISTLIST OFOF ABBREABBREVVAATIONSTIONS 22 MEMORIAL ON BEHALF OF RESPON&ENTMEMORIAL ON BEHALF OF RESPON&ENT

6TH NATIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 20166TH NATIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION, 2016

AA 5555 rreeiiaa 11 iioo 44 MMeeaa 44 ii 44 ;; && AAnndd CCrriimm..LL..JJ.. CCrriimmiinnaall LLaaww JJoorrnnaall !!..CC..CC.. !!""rr##mm## CCoorr$$ CCaa%%##%% AA..II..RR.. AAllll IInnddiiaa RR##oorrdd CCrr.. PPCC CCrriimmiinnaall PPrroo##ddrr## CCoodd## ''.. ((##rr%%%% IIPPCC IInnddiiaann PP##nnaall CCoodd## JJJJ AA$$ JJ''##nniill## JJ%%$$ii## ))CCaarr## aanndd PPrroo$$##$$iioonn** AA$$,, 22000000 J JJJ RRll##%% JJ''##nniill## JJ%%$$ii## ))CCaarr## aanndd PPrroo$$##$$iioonn** RRll##%%,, 220000 ++ JJ JJ''##nniill## JJ%%$$ii## ooaarrdd ww..##..-- ii$$// EE----##$$ rroomm ((ooll.. ((oollmm## EEdd.. EEddii$$iioonn ii..##..,, TT//aa$$ II%% IIdd.. IIiidd LL..JJ.. LLaaww JJoorrnnaall CCrrii CCrriimmiinnaall No.No. Nm#rNm#r AArr$$.. AArr$$iill## JJCC JJ''##nniill## ooaarrdd oommmmii$$$$#### !!CC !!""rr##mm## CCoorr$$ HHCC HHii// CCoorr$$ UU 33 %%.. UUnndd##rr !!##$$iioonn%% !#.!#. !#$ion!#$ion IIPPCC IInnddiiaann PP##nnaall CCoodd## 44 oo''$$.. 44 oo''##rrnnmm##nn$$ LL$$dd.. LLiimmii$$##dd AA..LL.. 55 .. AAnndd//rraa LL##aall JJddmm##nn$$%% JJCC JJ''##nniill## ooaarrdd CCoommmmii$$$$#### 33 MEMORIAL ON BEHALF OF RESPON&ENTMEMORIAL ON BEHALF OF RESPON&ENT

M.P. Mad/a Prad#%/ U.P. U$$ar Prad#%/ H.P. Hima/al Prad#%/ Anr. Ano$/#r Or%. O$/#r% !.C.R. !"r#m# Cor$ R#"or$#r !"". !.C.R. !""l#m#n$ar !"r#m# Cor$ R#"or$#r M.L.J. Madra% Law Jornal ALL CC Alla/aad Criminal Ca%#% A.L.J. Alla/aad Law Jornal% Cal. Cal$$a 5 .L.T. 5 #l/i Law Tim#% I.L.R Indian Law R#"or$% J.L.J. Jaal"r Law Jornal% !.C.A.L.E. !"r#m# Cor$ Almana IN&E+ OF AUTHORITIES 4

CASES REFERRE& AN& CITE&:<

1. 4o'inda C/andra '. !$a$# o- #%$ #nal, 17++ Crim.L.J. 1877 9 A.I.R. 17++ Cal. :+1 )..*
2. !$a$# o- Mad/a Prad#%/ '. adri ;ada', 2006 Crim.L.J. 212< a$ ". 21:1 )!.C.* :. A%/wani =mar !a>#na '. !$a$# o- M.P., )2012* 7 !.C.C. +?
3. Mor Pal '. !$a$#, ) 20 1:* 17< 5.L.T. 8<+ ?. Ji$#ndra !in/ @aoo !in/ and Anr. '. !$a$# o- U.P., )201:* : RCR )Criminal* <
4. Par$a" !in/ '. !$a$# o- H.P., 200: Crim.L.J. 2<+8 )200:* 8 R#. Cr.R. 278. +. !$a$# o- i/ar '. RaB#ndra Arawalla, 1776 )1* AL5)Cri.* :<  )1776* < !.C.C. 168 <. Mr%. R"an 5#al aBaB and Anr. '. =anwar Pal !in/ 4ill and Anr., A.I.R. 1776 !.C. :07  )177?* 6 !.C.C. 178
5. !$a$# o- i/ar '. Mrad Ali =/an, 17<7 Crim.L.J. 100?
6. =ri%/nan '. !$a$#, )200:* + !.C.C. )Cri.* 1?++
7. 4irBa !/anar '. !$a$# o- U.P., )2008* : !.C.C. +7: 2008 !.C.C. )Cri.* <6:
8. Jai /awan '. !$a$# o- Harana, )1777* : !.C.C. 102 1:. 5ar%/an !in/ '. !$a$# o- PnBa, )2010* : !.C.C. )Cri.* 266 )2007*16 !.C.C. 270
9. !r#%/ '. !$a$# o- U.P., )2001* : !.C.C. 6+: 2001 !.C.C. )Cri.* 601 1?. 4oda""a '. !$a$# o- =arna$aa, )201:* 2 !.C.C. )Cri.* < )201:* : !.C.C. 6+?
10. 4o"i Na$/ '. !$a$#, )2001* 6 !.C.C. 620 1+. Nand '. !$a$#, )2002* < !.C.C. 7 1<. A%/o =mar '. !$a$# o- PnBa, 17++ Crim.L.J. 168
11. !a/in '. !$a$#, )200<* : !.C.C. :
12. !/anarlal =ar/ar/ai '. !$a$#, A.I.R. 176? !.C. 12 60
13. Para%a RaBa '. !$a$#, )200:* 12 !.C.C. :06 A.I.R. 2008 !.C. 1:2 2008 Crim.L.J. :
14. 5ani !in/ '. !$a$#, )2008* 1: !.C.C. 20: A.I.R. 2008 !C 8?+0 2008 Crim.L.J. :2:< 2:. 5/aram"al '. !$a$#, A.I.R. 17+< !C 1782 17+< Crim.L.J. 1+
15. Anand '. !$a$#, A.I.R. 1766 !C 18< 1766 Crim.L.J. 1+ 2?. Joind#r '. !$a$#, 1778 Crim.L.J. 1:8 )!.C.*
16. Ma%odan '. !$a$# o- U.P., A.I.R. 17<< !.C. 126 2+. /awan '. !$a$#, )17+<* 1 !.C.C. 218 17+< Crim.L.J. 1?: 2<. Adl ari '. !$a$# o- #%$ #nal, 17<8 Crim.L.J. 201 )Cal.*
17. Prad##" =mar '. Union o- Admn., )2006* 10 !.C.C. 60< A.I.R. 2006 !.C. 277 2 2006 Crim.L.J. :< BOOKS REFERRE&:<
18. 2 R. N. CHOU5HR;, LA RELATIN4 TO JU(ENILE JU!TICE IN IN5IA )R. P. =a$aria & !.=.A. NaD'i #d%., 2 nd #d. 200<*
19. !. P. !EN 4 UPTA, !AR=AR & JU!TICE =HA!T4IR ON IN5IAN PENAL CO5E, 1<60 )=amal Law Ho%# #d%., 201?* :. 1 !. C. !AR=AR , THE I N5IAN PENAL CO5E, 1<60 )5wi'#di Law A#n Alla/aad #d%., Arid#d Coni%# #d. 200+*
20. 2 !. C. !AR=AR & P. C. !AR=AR , !arar THE CO5E O CRIMINAL PROCE5URE, 17 +: )L#>i%N#>i% #d%., !di"$o !arar #d. 201?* ?. . M 4 AN5HI, I N5IA N PENAL CO5E, 1<60 )2nd #d. 2006* 5

6. =. =. I;EN4AR , COMMENTAR; ON THE CO5E O CRIMINAL PROCE5URE , 17+: )

nd #d. 2011* +. = (^5 4) AUR , CRIMINAL LA CA!E! AN5 MATERIAL! )8$/^ #d. 200?* STATUTES REFERRE&:<

1. I N5IAN PENAL CO5E, ACT NO. 8? O 1<
2. CO5E O CRIMINAL PROCE5URE, ACT NO. 2 (^) O 17+ :. I N5IAN E(I5ENCE ACT, ACT NO. 1 O 1<+
3. JU(ENILE JU!TICE )CARE AN5 PROTECTION O CHIL5REN* ACT, ACT NO. ?6 O 2000 ?. JU(ENILE JU!TICE R ULE!, 200+
4. THE CON!TITUTION O I N5IA EBSITES REFERRE&:<
5. Man"a$ra, /$$" 33 www.man"a$ra-a%$.in )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 1+, 2016*
6. L#>i%N#>i%, /$$"3 3 www.l#>i%n#>i%.om )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 11, 2016 * :. #%$law, /$$"3 3 www.w#%$law.om )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 12, 2016 *
7. O>-ord 5i$ionari#%, /$$"3 3 www.o>-orddi$ionari#%.om )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 16, 2016 * ?. !"r#m# Cor$ o- India, /$$"3 3 www.Bdi%.ni.in )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 18, 2016* =. T/# Law 5i$ionar, /$$"33www.$/#lawdi$ionar.or )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 1<, 2016* +. !"r#m# Cor$ Ca%#%, /$$" 33 www.or$ni.ni.in )la%$ 'i%i$#d  #rar 1?, 2016* LE*AL &ICTIONARIES:<
8. LAC=! LA 5 ICTIONAR; +12 ) $/ #d. 2007*.
9. ILLIAM P. !TAT!=;, LE4AL THE!AURU! 5 ICTIONAR; )#%$ Pli%/in #d%., : rd #d. 17<6* :. 5 R. = ATHE; ROONE;, LOOM!UR; CONCI!E E N4LI!H 5 ICTIONAR; )loom%r Pli%/in Pl. #d%., 2 nd #d. 200?*
10. CATHERINE !OANE! & AN4U! !TE(EN!ON, CONCI!E OFOR5 EN4LI!H 5 ICTIONAR; )O>-ord Uni'#r%i$ Pr#%% #d%., 11 $/ #d. 2008* 6

STATEMENT OF ,URIS&ICTION

THE APPELLANTS HAVE THE HONOUR TO SUBMIT BEFORE THE HON’BLE

SUPREME COURT OF EUREKA> THE MEMORAN&UM FOR THE APPELLANTS

UN&ER ART.$?=

$ (SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION) OF THE IN&IAN CONSTITUTION IN THE INSTANT MATTER OF &AVI& ' ANR. . STATE OF AL&HIEM. THE RESPON&ENTS RESERVE THE RIHT TO CHALLENE THE ,URIS&ICTION. THE PRESENT MEMORAN&UM SETS FORTH THE FACTS> CONTENTIONS AN& AR*UMENTS. 1 S2e6ia3 Leae 1o a22ea3 5@ 1e S82reme Co8r1 G No$wi$/%$andin an$/in in $/i% /a"$#r, $/# !"r#m# Cor$ ma, in i$% di%r#$ion, ran$ %"#ial l#a'# $o a""#al -rom an Bdm#n$, d#r##, d#$#rmina$ion, %#n$#n# or ord#r in an a%# or ma$$#r "a%%#d or mad#  an or$ or $rinal in $/# $#rri$or o- India.

2. No$/in in $/i% la%# )1* %/all a""l $o an Bdm#n$, d#$#rmina$ion, %#n$#n#, or ord#r "a%%#d or mad#  an or$ or $rinal on%$i$$#d  or nd#r an law r#la$in $o $/# arm#d -or#%. 7

$.$ INUIR- BEFORE THE ,UVENILE BOAR& COMMITTEE:

T/# on%#l /ml %mi$% $/a$ w/#n#'#r a a%# i% "r#%#n$#d #-or# $/# JC, i$ /old% an inDir in aordan# wi$/ $/# "ro'i%ion% m#n$ion#d in JJ A$, 2000 8 and ma#% %/ ord#r in r#la$ion $o $/# B'#nil# a% i$ d##m% -i$ ?

. I- $/# JC i% %a$i%-i#d wi$/ $/# -a$ $/a$ a%#d i% a J'#nil# on $/# da$# o- ommi%%ion o- $/# o--#n# and i% il$ o- $/# o--#n#, $/#n $/# JC anno$ $ran%-#r $/# a%# o- B'#nil# $o $/# !#%%ion% Cor$ in aordan# wi$/ $/# Prini"l# o- NonGai'#r o- Ri/$% 6 m#n$ion#d in Rl# : %Grl# )2* la%# )IF* o- JJ Rl#%, 200+

. T/# Prini"l# o- Non  ai'#r o- Ri/$% la% down $/a$ #a -uvenile 'annot be 'ommitted to a hi!her 'ourt if he is a -uvenile( , w/i/ $/# JC /a% $o aid#  w/il# d#idin a a%# #i$/#r in -a'or o- $/# a%#d or aain%$ /im, -r$/#r $/i% an # l#arl %aid on $/# a%i% o- Rl# : la%# )1* w/i/ %$a$#% $/a$ $/# JC /a% $o aid#  $/# rl# m#n$ion#d Rl# : o- $/# JJ Rl#%, 200+. T/# Rl# : la%# )1* r#ad a%  ,The State overnment" the Juvenile Justi'e Board" the Child +elfare Committee or other 'om%etent authorities or a!en'ies" as the 'ase may be" hile im%lementin! the %rovisions of these rules shall abide and be !uided by the %rin'i%les" s%e'ified in sub rule 2/. I$ i% on$#nd#d $/a$, $/i% i% /i/l im"roal# $/a$ $/# JC wold rl# aain%$ $/# a-or#m#n$ion#d "rini"l# and $/# Prini"l# o- #%$ In$#r#%$ < $o d#id# #rron#o%l and $ran%-#r $/# a%# o- $/# a%#d $o $/# adl$ or$ i.#., $/# !#%%ion% Cor$  'iola$in $/# Rl#% m#n$ion#d in $/# JJ Rl#%, 200+. T/# d#i%ion "ronon#d  $/# JC in $/# $rial o- 4 w.#.-. A"ril 1, 2001 5 !#. 18 J'#nil# J%$i# A$ No. ?6 o- 2000. 6 Prini"l# o- NonG ai'#r o- Ri/$%: no wai'#r o- ri/$% o- $/# /ild or B'#nil# in on-li$ wi$/ law, w/#$/#r  /im%#l- or $/# om"#$#n$ a$/ori$ or anon# a$in or laimin $o a$ on #/al- o- $/# B'#nil# or /ild, i% #i$/#r "#rmi%%il# or 'alid. 7 w.#.- O$o#r 26, 200+ 8 Rl# :9 !G Rl# )29 Cla%# )I(* o- $/# JJ Rl#%, 200+ w.#.-. O$o#r 26, 200+. 14

A""#llan$ Nm#r 1 %$a$#% $/a$G the Juvenile Board found avid to be ell aare of the 'ir'umstan'es and 'onsequen'es of his a't and therefore 'ommit his 'ase to Sessions Court findin! him Ca%a& of 'ommittin! an offen'e 4 . or $/# lari$ o- $/# Honl# or$ $/# on%#l wold li# $o draw $/# a$$#n$ion o- $/# Honl# Cor$ $oward% $/# %ini-ian# o- word Ca%a& %#d  $/# !#%%ion% Cor$ w/il# r#B#$in $/# %mi%%ion o- $/# A""#llan$ No. 1. T/# m#anin o- $/# $#rm Ca%a&^10 i% #bein! 'a%able of 'ommittin! a 'rime es%e'ially ith referen'e to the a!e(^11. I$ i% #'id#n$ -rom $/# m#anin o- $/# $#rm %#d  $/# JC $/a$ $/# JC /a% $a#n "ro"#r m#a%r#% and /a% -ollow#d $/# rl#% a% m#n$ion#d in JJ Rl#%, 200+ w/il# d#idin $/# a%# o- A""#llan$ No. 1 )i.#., 5a'id. I$ i% al%o l#ar $/a$ d#i%ion  $/# JC i% orr#$ law and $/#r# i% no "la# -or ill#ali$ in $/# %aid Bdm#n$. T/# on%#l -r$/#r on$#nd% $/a$ !#. 8 Cla%# ): 12 o- $/# JJ A$, 200+, m#n$ion% $/a$ no Mai%$ra$# i% a""oin$#d $o $/# JC nl#%% /# /a% %"#ial nowl#d# or $rainin in /ild "%/olo. T/%, $/# on%#l anowl#d#% $/# #>"#r$i%# o- $/# Mai%$ra$# o- $/# JC, -or -indin $/a$ 5a'id wa% w#ll awar# o- $/# irm%$an#% o- /i% a$.  analin $/# ao'# %$a$#m#n$ i$ i% l#ar $/a$ $/# JC old #a%il loa$# $/# m#ri$% in $/# a%# o- $/# A""#llan$ No. 1 r#ardin o$/ /i% in$#n$ion and $/# aili$ $o ommi$ $/# o--#n# alon wi$/ $/# r#a%onin o- /i% a#. T/# on%#l -r$/#r %##% $/# a$$#n$ion o- $/# Honl# or$ on $/# -a$ %/##$ $/a$ i$ i% %il#n$ ao$ an i%%# rai%#d or %mi%%ion% mad#  $/# A""#llan$ #-or# $/# JC r#ardin /i% a# w/#n $/# a%# wa% nd#r $rial #-or# $/#m. T/%, $/# on%#l i% o- $/# 'i#w $/a$ $/# JC wa% %a$i%-i#d $/a$ $/# a""#llan$ /ad $/# m#n$al a"ai$ $o ommi$ $/# 9 Su%ra No$# 2 10 5oli Ca"a> 5##m#d a"al# o- -ormin $/# in$#n$ $o ommi$ a rim# or $or$, #%"#iall  r#a%on o- a#.9 www.o>-orddi$ionari#%.om 11 la% Law 5i$ionar +12 )7$/^ #d. 2007* CAPAF, 5OLL. La$. Ca"al# o- ommi$$in rim#, or a"al# o- riminal in$#n$. T/# "/ra%# d#%ri#% $/# ondi$ion o- on# w/o /a% %--ii#n$ in$#lli#n# and om"r#/#n%ion $o # /#ld riminall r#%"on%il# -or /i% d##d%. 12 !#. 8 Cla%# ):* o- JJ A$, 2001 No Mai%$ra$# %/all # a""oin$#d a% a m#m#r o- $/# oard nl#%% /# /a% %"#ial nowl#d# or $rainin in /ild "%/olo or /ild w#l-ar# and no %oial wor#r %/all # a""oin$#d a% a m#m#r o- $/# oard nl#%% /# /a% ##n a$i'#l  in'ol'#d in /#al$/, #da$ion, or w#l-ar# a$i'i$i#% "#r$ainin $o /ildr#n -or a$ l#a%$ %#'#n #ar%. 15

rim#. T/%, an #rror in $/# Bdm#n$ o- $/# J'#nil# J%$i# oard anno$ # o%#r'#d $/#r#in. $." THE TRIAL BEFORE THE SESSIONS COURT: T/# on%#l /ml %mi$% #-or# $/# Honl# Cor$, $/a$ %in# $/# JC /ad a%#d no #rror in ommi$$in $/# a%# o- A""#llan$ No.G1 $o $/# !#%%ion% Cor$ 1:, $/# !#%%ion% Cor$ /a% $/#r#-or# no$ a%#d an a%# o- law in /#arin /i% "#$i$ion. T/# Con%#l -r$/#r on$#nd% $/a$, $/a$ a-$#r $/# a%# wa% ommi$$#d $o $/# !#%%ion% Cor$  J'#nil# oard Commi$$##, all $/# "ro##din% o- !#%%ion or$ will /a'# $o # ond$#d in aordan# wi$/ $/# "ro#dr# #%$ali%/#d  $/# Cod# o- Criminal Pro#dr#, 17+: 18 and $/# a%# i% $o # o"#n#d  $/# "ro%#$ion nd#r !#. 226 1? o- $/# Cr. PC, 17+: w/i/ i% in'o#d  $/# !#. 207 o- $/# Cr. PC, 17+:. In $/# $rail "ro#%%, $/ro/ !#$ion 2: 16 o- Cr. PC, 17+:, i- an a%#d do#% no$ #$ aDi$$#d, $/#n $/# a%# #n$#r% "on d#-#n# $/ro/ !#. 2:: 1+ o- $/# Cr. PC, 17+: w/i/ r#ad% a%  ,5nterin! u%on defen'e 0 1 here the a''used is not a'quitted under se'tion 232 he shall be 'alled u%on to enter on his defen'e and addu'e any eviden'e he may have in su%%ort thereof. 13 Su%ra No$# : 14 w.#.- A"ril 1, 17+ 15 Se6. ""= o0 Cr. PC> $? < /#n $/# a%#d a""#ar% or i% ro/$ #-or# $/# Cor$ in "r%an# o- a ommi$m#n$ o- $/# a%# nd#r %#$ion 207, $/# "ro%#$or %/all o"#n /i% a%#   d#%riin $/# /ar# ro/$ aain%$ $/# a%#d and %$a$in  w/a$ #'id#n# /# "ro"o%#% $o "ro'# $/# il$ o- $/# a%#d 16 Se6. "?" o0 Cr. PC> $? G I- a-$#r $ain $/# #'id#n# -or $/# "ro%#$ion, #>aminin $/# a%#d and /#arin $/# "ro%#$ion and $/# d#-#n# on $/# "oin$, $/# Jd# on%id#r% $/a$ $/#r# i% no #'id#n# $/a$ $/# a%#d ommi$$#d $/# o--#n#9 $/# Bd# %/all r#ord an ord#r o- aDi$$al. 17 Se6. "?? o0 Cr. PC> $? )1* w/#r# $/# a%#d i% no$ aDi$$#d nd#r %#$ion 2:2 /# %/all # all#d "on $o #n$#r on /i% d#-#n# and add# an #'id#n# /# ma /a'# in %""or$ $/#r#o-. )2* I- $/# a%#d "$% in an wri$$#n %$a$#m#n$, $/# Jd# %/all -il# i$ wi$/ $/# r#ord. ):* I- $/# a%#d a""li#% -or $/# i%%# o- an "ro#%% -or om"#llin $/# a$$#ndan# o- an wi$n#%% or $/# "rod$ion o- an dom#n$ or $/in, $/# Jd# %/all i%%# %/ "ro#%% nl#%% /# on%id#r%, -or r#a%on% $ o # r#ord#d, $/a$ %/ a""lia$ion %/old # r#-%#d on $/# rond $/a$ i$ i% mad# -or $/# "r"o%# o- '#>a$ion or d#la or -or d#-#a$in $/# #nd% o- B%$i#. 16

2 If the a''used %uts in any ritten statement" the Jud!e shall file it ith the re'ord. 3 If the a''used a%%lies for the issue of any %ro'ess for 'om%ellin! the attendan'e of any itness or the %rodu'tion of any do'ument or thin!" the Jud!e shall issue su'h %ro'ess unless he 'onsiders" for reasons to be re'orded" that su'h a%%li'ation should be refused on the !round that it is made for the %ur%ose of ve&ation or delay or for defeatin! the ends of -usti'e./ I$ i% l#ar -rom $/# ao'# %$a$#m#n$ $/a$ !#. 2:: Cla%# ):* l#arl %$a$#% $/a$ i- $/# d#-#n# wan$#d $o "rod# an o- dom#n$ or $/in $/# Bd# %/all i%%# i$ nl#%% /# $/in% $/a$ i$ %/old # r#-%#d on $/# rond% o- '#>a$ion or d#la. I$ i% $/#r#-or# on$#nd#d $/a$ $/# B'#nil# wa% i'#n $/# -ll ri/$ $o "rod# an #'id#n# on /i% #/al- -or d#$#rminin /i% a# and onl w/#n /# wa% nal# $o do %o $/# !#%%ion% Cor$ r#B#$#d /i% arm#n$ w/i/ i% orr#$ in law. E'#n nd#r !#$ion 2:: Cr. PC, 17+: $/# a%#d an #n$#r "on d#-#n# and /# an a""l -or $/# i%%# o- an "ro#%% -or om"#llin $/# a$$#ndan# o- an wi$n#%% in /i% d#-#n# 1<

. H#r#, $/# d#-#n# i% i'#n $/# o""or$ni$ $o "rod# an %/ dom#n$ or #'id#n# $/a$ wold l#ad l$ima$#l $o /i% aDi$$al. T/# Con%#l -r$/#r on$#nd% in aordan# wi$/ !#. 10: o- Indian E'id#n# A$, 1<+ 17 $/a$ i- a -a$ i% nown onl $o a "#r%on, $/# rd#n o- "ro'in $/# %a m# li#% in /i% /and% onl. T/%, i$ an # %aid $/# w/ol# rd#n in $/# "r#%#n$ a%# wa% "on A""#llan$ No. 1 )i.#., 5a'id* $o "rod# $/# #'id#n# o- /i% B'#nili$, "ro'id#d /# /ad %%$an$ial #'id#n# -or $/# %am# in $/# a%#n# o- w/i/ $/# !#%%ion% Cor$ o#% on $o r#B#$ /i% %mi%%ion %$a$in $/a$  # there as insuffi'ien'y of eviden'e of a!e( 26 . A on$#n$ion -r$/#r ari%#% $/a$, nd#r !#$ion +)A* 21 o- $/# JJ A$, 2000, i$ i% "on $/# %/old#r% o- $/# J'#nil# oard Commi$$##, $o "ro'# and %a$i%- an laim o- B'#nili$ o- a "#r%on. $, in $/# a%# o- Ashwani Kumar Saxena v. State of M.P. 22 , $/# Honl# Cor$ /#ld $/a$  K7n'e the 'ourt" folloin! the above mentioned %ro'edures" %asses an order8 that order shall be the 'on'lusive %roof of the a!e as re!ards su'h 'hild or -uvenile in 'onfli't ith 18 !$a$# o- Mad/a Prad#%/ '. adri ;ada', 2006 Crim.L.J. 212< a$ ". 21:1 )!C* 19 Act no. 1 of 1872 20 !$a$#m#n$ o- a$% ParaG 11 17

intentionally ta@en" for the %ur%ose of #effe'tin! felony(  61 !imilar 'i#w wa% /#ld in $/# a%#% o-. T/%, $/# Con%#l /ml %mi$% $/a$ A""#llan$ Nm#rG2% a$ o- indlin in a "ror#%%i'# Dil#, Darr#l and -i/$ wa% a %$#" $oward% $/# a$ion o- ommi$$in o- $/# l$ima$# o--#n#  A""#llan$ Nm#rG1. Al%o, $/# a""#llan$ no. 2 did no$ %$o" $/# a""#llan$ -rom ommi$$in $/# a$. T/%, i$ i% l#ar -rom $/# a-or#m#n$ion#d a%# $/a$ $/#r# wa% ommon in$#n$ion #$w##n o$/ $/# a""#llan$% w/il# ommi$$in $/# rim#. In $/# a%# o- /ani Sin$h . State 72 , $/# Honl# or$ /#ld $/a$G KCommon Intention does not mean same or similar intention. It im%lies %rearran!ed %lan and a'tin! in 'on'ert %ursuant to the said %lan. Thou!h it may develo% on the s%ot" it must be anterior in %oint of time.  T/%, r#lin on $/# ao'# m#n$ion#d a%# i$ i% on$#nd#d $/a$ a "r#Gon#r$#d "lan i% a n##%%ar $o /old !#. :8 o- IPC, 1<60 a""lial#. $ $/# "lannin or m##$in o- mind an /a""#n in a %"r o- mo'#m#n$ w/i/ i% #'id#n$ -rom $/# -a$ %/##$ $/a$ i$ wa% %o in $/# "r#%#n$ a%#. In $/# a%# o- /haram+a . State 6: and Anan# . State 7* $/# Honl# or$ /#ld $/a$ in$#n$ion $o ommi$ a rim# ma d#'#lo" on $/# %"o$ and i$ i% no$ n##%%ar $/a$ $/#r# m%$ # %om# $im#Gla #$w##n $/# -orma$ion o- ommon in$#n$ion and $/# a$al ommi%%ion o- $/# o--#n# in -r$/#ran# o- %/ ommon in$#n$ion. Al%o, in $/# a%# o- "o$in#er . State 76 $/# Honl# Cor$ /#ld $/a$G 61 R%%#l on Crim#, 12$/^ Edn. (ol I."".8<+ and 8<< 62 )20081: !.C.C. 20: A.I.R. 2008 !C 8?+0 2008 CrLJ :2:< 63 A.I.R. 17+< !C 1782 17+< CrLJ 1+ 64 A.I.R. 1766 !C 18< 1766 CrLJ 1+ 65 1778 CrLJ 1:8 )!C 28

KThe totality of the 'ir'umstan'es must be ta@en into 'onsideration. The %re arran!ed %lan may develo% on the s%ot. 66 T/# Con%#l -r$/#r on$#nd% $/a$ #'#n in $/# "r#%#n$ a%# $/# a$% o- UBwal Pro/i$ wa% a %$#" $a#n in$#n$ionall  /im $o a$$ain $/# l$ima$# -#lon o- a%in ra'# inBr $o Mo/an. T/# -a$or o- "lannin or m##$in o- mind% i% #'id#n$ 6+ -rom $/# -a$ %/##$ w/i/ %a%, K 5a'id aom"ani#d UBwal Pro/i$ and $oo an iron rod and ar#%%i'#l %$ri# i$ on $/# /#ad o- Mo/an, r#%l$in w/i/ o o$ -ain$#d 6<

. T/# $#rm aom"ani#d 67  i% a $ran%i$i'# '#r w/i/ m#an%, $o o alon wi$/ or om"l#m#n$ %om#on# or %om#$/in. T/%, $/# on$#n$ion /#ld #-or# $/# Honl# Cor$, "lannin an #a%il # d#ri'#d -rom a$% o- $/# A""#llan$% nd#r !#. :8 o- $/# IPC, 1<60. !in# $/# a$ o- A""#llan$ Nm#rG1)i.#., 5a'id* in #$$in in$o a -i$ o- ar#%%ion and /i$$in Mo/an wa% %o "ro>ima$# $o $/# a$ o- A""#llan$ No. 2 )i.#., UBwal Pro/i$* o- #$$in in'ol'#d in a -i/$ w/i/ in i$%#l- m#an% in'ol'#m#n$ o- 'iol#n# and ar#%%ion

, $/a$ o$/ $/# a$% an # orr#la$#d

and $/% i$ old # onld#d $/a$ $/#r# wa% ommon in$#n$ion amon o$/ $/# a""#llan$% $o ommi$ $/# rim#. I$ i% on$#nd#d $/a$ in $/# a%# o- Pra#ee+ Kumar (^) . )nion of A#mn^32 $/# Honl# or$ $al% ao$ $/# or%# o- #'#n$% w/i/ $oo "la# d# $o a%#d a-$#r $/# a$ wa% ommi$$#d. T/# Con%#l %##% a$$#n$ion o- $/# Honl# Cor$ $oward% $/# -a$ $/a$, A""#llan$ Nm#rG2, a-$#r $/# ommi%%ion o- o--#n#  A""#llan$ Nm#r 1, K understandin! the 'ir'umstan'es Eed from that %la'e immediately. +: T/%, $/# ond$ o- A""#llan$ Nm#rG 2 a-$#r $/# orrin o- $/# o--#n# /i/li/$% $/# "r#%#n# o- il$ in /i% mind. 66 Ma%odan '. !$a$# o- U.P. A.I.R. 17<< !C 126 67 /awan '. !$a$# )17+<* 1 !.C.C. 218 17+< Crim.L.J. 1?: 68 a$%/##$ "ara.? 69 Ca$/#rin# !oan#% & An% !$#'#n%on, Coni%# O>-ord Enli%/ 5i$ionar)11$/^ Edi$ion, 2008* 70 Su%ra No$# 2? 71 Adl ari '. !$a$# o- #%$ #nal 17<8 CrLJ 201)Cal* 72 )2006* 10 !.C.C. 60< A.I.R. 2006 !C 2772 2006 Crim.L.J. :< 29

T/# Con%#l %mi$% #-or# $/# Honl# Cor$ $/a$ on%id#rin all $/# ao'# a$/ori$i#% i$#d and $/# on$#n$ion% mad# in on%onan# wi$/ $/#%# a$/ori$i#%, $/# irm%$an$ial #'id#n#, ndo$#dl "oin$% $oward% A""#llan$ Nm#rG2 )i.#., UBwal Pro/i$* $/a$ /# /ad $/# ommon in$#n$ion, a% d#-in#d nd#r !#. :8 o- $/# IPC, 1<60 alon wi$/ A""#llan$ Nm#rG )i.#., 5a'id* $o 'oln$aril a%# ri#'o% /r$ $o $/# now d##a%#d Mo/an w/i/ l#d $o $/# d#a$/ o- Mo/an. PRA-ER +herefore" in the li!ht of the fa'ts %resented" issues raised" ar!uments advan'ed and authorities 'ited" the :es%ondents humbly submits that the on(ble Court be %leased to ad-ud!e and de'lare thatF

1. The 'ase of <%%ellant ?o. 1 i.e." avid should not be remanded ba'@ to the Juvenile Board Committee.
2. The %unishment of the <%%ellant no. 2 i.e." -al Purohit should not be sus%ended. <nd %ass any other relief" that this on(ble Court may deem fit and %ro%er in the interest of -usti'e" equity and !ood 'ons'ien'e. )or this a't of @indness" the :es%ondents shall duty bound forever %ray. !d. 3G )Con%#l -or $/# R#%"ond#n$%* 73 !$a$#m#n$ o- a$%9 ParaG 30