
















Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
The claim that Horace Walpole's 'The Castle of Otranto' was the origin of the Christmas ghost story tradition. The author delves into the history of the publication, the connections to St. Nicholas, and the supernatural elements of the novel. Despite some evidence suggesting a link, the document concludes that there is a lack of definitive proof that Walpole intended his work as a Christmas ghost story.
Typology: Slides
1 / 24
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!

















The Castle of Otranto as Christmas Ghost Story Conor B. Hilton The tradition of telling ghost stories at Christmas has long been associated with Victorian England, especially Charles Dickens and A Christmas Carol. However, Nick Groom, author of “Gothic Antiquity” the first chapter in the catalogue of the current British Library exhibition Terror and Wonder: The Gothic Imagination , writes, “this year is the 250th anniversary of Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto , first published on Christmas Eve 1764 as a seasonal ghost story” (“There is no escape”). Here, Groom places Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto firmly within the Christmas ghost story tradition, moving the origin back almost a century from Dickens. Interestingly, Groom tempers the claim slightly in the “Introduction” to the 2014 Oxford World Classics edition of The Castle of Otranto , writing “Indeed, the publication of Otranto on Christmas Eve perhaps reflected the seasonal tradition of telling ghostly stories at this time of year” (Groom xxx-xxxi). Groom’s claim of the “seasonal ghost story” roots of Otranto may have some earlier roots in the work of Montague Summers. As early as 1934, Summers wrote (quoting himself from a decade earlier) “It is hardly an exaggeration to say that to Walpole’s romance is due the ghost story and the novel, containing so much of the supernatural and occult, than which no forms of literature are now [1923] more common and applauded” (179). Summers does not necessarily link the ghost story to the tradition of seasonal Christmas Eve ghost tales, but does cite Otranto as the origin of ghost stories and novels (the latter a claim that would be contested by essentially all literary scholars). However, there is a dearth of research that verifies the claim that Otranto was intended as a seasonal ghost story and influenced the tradition that Dickens wrote in. In this paper, I will begin to fill the void,
extending the traditional narrative of the Christmas ghost story tradition and seeking to establish The Castle of Otranto ’s place in that narrative. There is some precedent for looking beyond Dickens to find the origins of the Christmas ghost story. “Dickens was responding to a convention well established before he penned the unrivalled perfection of Scrooge's four redemptive spirits. For people of the northern hemisphere, supernatural tales told around the hearth during the darkest hours of the year roll back further than the yule log” (M. Gray). Yet, claims such as these jump from Dickens to pagan traditions centuries prior, leaving hundreds of years in between, with no clear delineation of the tradition continuing. Placing Otranto in the narrative requires some work connecting Otranto to A Christmas Carol and also establishing the origins of the tradition pre- Otranto. The Christmas ghost story tradition appears to date back to at least 1732, some thirty years prior to Otranto , with the publication of Round About Our Coal Fire. “And now I come to another Entertainment, which is frequently used, which is of the Storytelling Order, viz. of Hobgoblins, Witches, Conjurers, Ghosts, Fairies, and such like common Disturbers” ( Round About 11). The text is a collection of traditions related to Christmastime, but the vast majority is devoted to different varieties of scary stories ( Round About 11-42). The tradition is in place to some extent prior to Walpole’s publication, yet the existence of the tradition is not enough to confirm that Walpole was writing in the tradition. To complicate the narrative, Sasha Handley has written extensively on the tradition of ghost stories in eighteenth century England, noting “The early decades of the eighteenth century saw such values increasingly prioritized by writers like Daniel Defoe. The moral lessons taught by Defoe’s ghosts in his History and Reality of Apparitions were firmly set within…1720” (137). Handley identifies that the ghost story was firmly set by at least 1720 with Defoe, adding a sense of legitimacy to the tradition’s presence in
this, the advertisements for the novel and the title page include the phrase “Canon of the Church of St. Nicholas at Otranto” (Otranto 1; “Advertisement for The Castle of Otranto ”). The connection between St. Nicholas and Christmas Eve seems too strong to not be a nod to the Christmas ghost story tradition. Particularly given the emphasis that Thomas Grey draws to it. “I have received the Castle of Otranto, and return you my thanks for it. It engages our attention here, makes some of us cry a little, and all in general afraid to go to-beds o’nights. We take it for a translation, and should believe it to be a true story, if it were not for St. Nicholas.” (T. Gray 266). For Gray, the text was believable except for St. Nicholas. What did Grey mean by this? What is it about St. Nicholas that caused Grey to doubt the veracity of the text? It must have been something quite impressive to be more convincing than the giant sable helmet falling from the sky and crushing a boy in the first three pages. It is unclear what exactly Gray was referring, complicated by the importance of St. Nicholas to the plot of the novel. There are sixteen references to “St. Nicholas” in the text, with the majority of those serving as descriptions of the Church near the castle. These references suggest an interesting relationship to the saint, but one that seems largely devoid of Christmas implications. St. Nicholas plays a prominent role in the resolution of the text. Frederic says “saint Nicholas appeared to me, and revealed a secret, which he bade me never disclose to mortal man, but on my death-bed” ( Otranto 81). Perhaps this is what Grey is referring to in his letter about disbelieving the story as a whole. Bleeding statues are acceptable, but the appearance of a saint to a man is simply unbelievable. More likely, the end of the tale may be the place of concern for Gray. “Behold in Theodore, the true heir of Alfonso! said the vision: and having pronounced those words, accompanied by a clap of thunder, it ascended solemnly towards heaven, where the clouds parting asunder, the form of saint Nicholas was seen; and receiving Alfonso’s shade, they were soon wrapt from mortal eyes in a blaze of
glory” ( Otranto 112-3). Here Saint Nicholas is seen in the sky enveloping the “Alfons This dramatic climax to the text may be the point that Gray is referring to in his letter. It is difficult to know clearly, what Gray meant. However, understanding some of the history of St. Nicholas’s connection to Christmas may address some o
Fig. 1. Ngram of “St. Nicholas.” Google. Web. 5 December 2014.
Usage of St. Nicholas in books appears to peak in around 1762 through the results of what books use St. Nicholas in this early period, it seems that the most common usage was to refer to churches and not to reference the St. Nick Nicholas” search). This seems to further distance the events of Otranto from the Christmas ghost story tradition, despite what appears to be an almost perfect storm in favor of it. However, the idea of St. Nicholas as a miraculous gift giver was well in place centuries before Walpole was writing (Handwerk). In fact, estimates place the tradition at aro least 300 years (Handwerk). The events of the Reformation put a damper on the tradition, but it is alive and well by the late-eighteenth century or early nineteenth century. This places Walpole in an awkward position, sandwiched between two voids, incorporating a saint that may or may
. Here Saint Nicholas is seen in the sky enveloping the “Alfons This dramatic climax to the text may be the point that Gray is referring to in his letter. It is difficult to know clearly, what Gray meant. However, understanding some of the history of St. Nicholas’s connection to Christmas may address some of the alternatives.
Fig. 1. Ngram of “St. Nicholas.” St. Nicholas, 1700-1900. Google Books Ngram Viewer.
. Web. 5 December 2014. Usage of St. Nicholas in books appears to peak in around 1762 (see figure 1). oks use St. Nicholas in this early period, it seems that the most common usage was to refer to churches and not to reference the St. Nick-Christmas tie This seems to further distance the events of Otranto from the Christmas ghost tory tradition, despite what appears to be an almost perfect storm in favor of it. However, the idea of St. Nicholas as a miraculous gift giver was well in place centuries before Walpole was writing (Handwerk). In fact, estimates place the tradition at around 1200, holding strong for at least 300 years (Handwerk). The events of the Reformation put a damper on the tradition, but it eighteenth century or early nineteenth century. This places Walpole ched between two voids, incorporating a saint that may or may . Here Saint Nicholas is seen in the sky enveloping the “Alfonso’s shade.” This dramatic climax to the text may be the point that Gray is referring to in his letter. It is difficult to know clearly, what Gray meant. However, understanding some of the history of St.
(see figure 1). Looking oks use St. Nicholas in this early period, it seems that the most Christmas tie (“St. This seems to further distance the events of Otranto from the Christmas ghost tory tradition, despite what appears to be an almost perfect storm in favor of it. However, the idea of St. Nicholas as a miraculous gift giver was well in place centuries before Walpole was und 1200, holding strong for at least 300 years (Handwerk). The events of the Reformation put a damper on the tradition, but it eighteenth century or early nineteenth century. This places Walpole ched between two voids, incorporating a saint that may or may
Fig. 2. Ngram of “Castle of Otranto.” Viewer. Google. Web. 5 December 2014. Moving to the post- Otranto suggests that the influence of the novel was felt throughout the lat century. The “Note on the Text” history to 1797, noting that “the third was in 1766, the fourt sixth (a reprint of the fifth) in 1791. Another edition (also known as the sixth) was printed at Parma in 1791 by Bodoni for Edwards. Others came in 1793 (two 1797” (xxxiv). This pattern of publication carries century. The continued popularity of the novel that broadens the scope of the text’s potential influence and therefore provides some leeway finding other texts that continue the Christmas ghost story tradition references to The Castle of Otranto This trajectory fits in neatly with the traditional narrative It also allows for Otranto to have a larger emphasis on the narrative than originally thought.
Fig. 2. Ngram of “Castle of Otranto.” Castle of Otranto, 1700-1900. Google Books Ngram
. Web. 5 December 2014. Otranto world, the publication history of The Castle of Otranto suggests that the influence of the novel was felt throughout the latter third of the eighteenth in the 2008 Oxford World Classics edition traces the publication history to 1797, noting that “the third was in 1766, the fourth in 1782, the fifth in 1786, and the sixth (a reprint of the fifth) in 1791. Another edition (also known as the sixth) was printed at Parma in 1791 by Bodoni for Edwards. Others came in 1793 (two editions), 1794, 1796, and ublication carries Otranto to 1797, just shy of the nineteenth century. The continued popularity of the novel is indicative of some level of cultural significance broadens the scope of the text’s potential influence and therefore provides some leeway finding other texts that continue the Christmas ghost story tradition. Not to mention that The Castle of Otranto in print rise until peaking shortly before 1840 (see figure 2). This trajectory fits in neatly with the traditional narrative concerning the Christmas ghost story. It also allows for Otranto to have a larger emphasis on the narrative than originally thought.
The Castle of Otranto of the eighteenth traces the publication h in 1782, the fifth in 1786, and the sixth (a reprint of the fifth) in 1791. Another edition (also known as the sixth) was printed at editions), 1794, 1796, and to 1797, just shy of the nineteenth is indicative of some level of cultural significance broadens the scope of the text’s potential influence and therefore provides some leeway in Not to mention that in print rise until peaking shortly before 1840 (see figure 2). concerning the Christmas ghost story. It also allows for Otranto to have a larger emphasis on the narrative than originally thought.
While it may not have been written as a Christmas ghost story, perhaps Otranto influenced the arc of the ghost story. The tradition appears to still be in place in 1819, with the serial publication of The Sketchbook of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. Washington Irving’s work contains a section that describes the events of a Christmas Eve. “When I returned to the drawing-room, I found the company seated round the fire, listening to the parson, who was deeply esconced [sic] in a high- backed oaken chair, the work of some cunning artificer of yore, which had been brought from the library for his particular accommodation” (Irving 208). Irving’s tale notes the tradition of gathering to hear tales and stories from a respected figure, in this case a parson. The invocation of a religious figure as the storyteller serves to lend credibility and weight to the merging of the Christian Christmas tradition to the supernatural, pagan or Gothic elements. The connection grows stronger as Irving continues: “From this venerable piece of furniture, with which his shadowy figure and dark weazen face so admirably accorded, he was dealing forth strange accounts of the popular superstitions and legends of the surrounding country, with which he had become acquainted in the course of his antiquarian researches” (208). Not only is the parson sharing stories and pieces of “yore,” but he is “dealing forth strange accounts of the popular superstitions and legends.” At least in Irving’s story, there is evidence of a tradition involving supernatural stories during the Christmas season. Almost a century separates Irving’s note of the tradition and the description found in Round About the Coal Fire , with Otranto providing a possible bridge as an example in print. Dickens publishes A Christmas Carol in 1843, with the full title giving away the tradition that Dickens is working in— A Christmas Carol in Prose Being a Ghost Story of Christmas. Perhaps it is due to this that scholars claim, “his [Dickens’] hugely successful Christmas Books
that Otranto was completely believable “if it were not for St. Nicholas” (266). The information that I found suggests that there is no intended connection between the St. Nicholas of Walpole’s text and the jolly, gift-bringer that we associated with Santa Claus. There appears to be a likely relationship between the winter tales of Shakespeare and older writers and the Christmas ghost stories that developed in the eighteenth century, yet the relationship is still unclear and therefore it is difficult to place Otranto in the middle of that narrative. The evidence suggests that there was no intention for The Castle of Otranto to be read as a Christmas ghost story. However, further research could yield insights into the relationship that Otranto has had with the development of the Christmas ghost story, with some promising signs, including the correlation between the rise in print references to Otranto and Christmas ghost stories during the Victorian period.
Works Cited and Consulted “Advertisement for The Castle of Otranto.” St. James Chronicle or the British Evening Post. 22- 25 Dec. 1764, Issue 594. 17th-18th Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 20 Nov 2014. Arts & Entertainment. Champion Or Evening Advertiser. 27 May 1740, Issue 84. 17 th-18th Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Arts & Entertainment. Lloyd's Evening Post and British Chronicle. 3-5 Mar. 1762, Issue 724. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Arts & Entertainment. Lloyd's Evening Post and British Chronicle. 14-16 April 1762, Issue 742. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Arts & Entertainment. London Chronicle. 20-22 Dec. 1757, Issue 153. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Arts & Entertainment. Public Advertiser. 11 Aug. 1766, Issue 9909. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Arts & Entertainment. St. James's Chronicle or the British Evening Post. 23-25 Mar. 1762, Issue
Classified ads. Gazetteer and New Daily Advertiser. 16 July 1766, Issue 11.652. 17 th-18th Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 17 April 1744, Issue 2940. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 22 Sept. 1744, Issue 3076. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 27 Aug. 1746, Issue 3693. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 28 May 1747, Issue 3910. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 29 May 1747, Issue 3910. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 17 June 1747, Issue 3945. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 23 June 1747, Issue 3950. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 17 Aug. 1748, Issue 4309. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 18 Aug. 1748, Issue 4310. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 7 Jan. 1749, Issue 4432. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.
Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 16 Jan. 1749, Issue 4433. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser. 10 Jan. 1749, Issue 4434. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 11 Jan. 1749, Issue 4435. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 12 Jan. 1749, Issue 4436. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 23 Jan. 1749, Issue 4439. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 24 Jan. 1749, Issue 4440. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. General Advertiser (1744). 5 Oct. 1749, Issue 4965. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Lloyd's Evening Post and British Chronicle. 11-13 Nov. 1761, Issue 676. 17 th-18th Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Lloyd's Evening Post and British Chronicle. 27-29 Oct. 1762, Issue 826. 17 th-18th Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Chronicle. 12-14 Nov. 1765, Issue 1390. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Daily Advertiser and Literary Gazette. 11 Oct. 1751, Issue 191. 17 th-18th Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.
Classified ads. London Evening Post. 19-21 Oct. 1749, Issue 3428. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Evening Post 8-19 Nov. 1753, Issue 4055. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Evening Post. 17 July 1756, Issue 4477. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Evening Post. 23-26 April 1757, Issue 4597. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Evening Post. 4-7 June 1757, Issue 4615. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. London Evening Post. 9-11 June 1757, Issue 4617. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 16 March 1756, Issue 6672. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 25 Oct. 1754, Issue 6237. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 1 Sept. 1766, Issue 6932. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser 9 April 1757, Issue 7006. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 11 April 1757, Issue 7007. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.
Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 7 June 1757, Issue 7056. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 8 June 1757, Issue 7056. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 13 Nov. 1761, Issue 8433. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 23 Feb. 1762, Issue 8520. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 8 Mar. 1762, Issue 8529. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 9 Mar. 1762, Issue 8530. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 26 March 1762, Issue 8547. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 25 Sept. 1762, Issue 8704. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 30 April 1763, Issue 8888. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 1 June 1763, Issue 8913. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. Classified ads. Public Advertiser. 3 June 1763, Issue 8914. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.
---. “There is no escape.” Horace Walpole and the terrifying rise of the Gothic. OUPblog. Oxford University Press. 3 Oct. 2014. Web. 25 Nov. 2014. Handley, Sasha. Visions of an Unseen World: Ghost Beliefs and Ghost Stories in Eighteenth- Century England. London: Pickering and Chatto, 2007. Print. Religious Cultures in the Early Modern World 2. Handwerk, Brian. “St. Nicholas to Santa: The Surprising Origins of Mr. Claus.” National Geographic. National Geographic. 20 Dec. 2013. Web. 28 Nov. 2014. Henson, Louise. “Investigations and Fictions: Charles Dickens and Ghosts.” The Victorian Supernatural. Eds. Nicola Brown, Carolyn Burdett, and Pamela Thurschwell. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004. 44-64. Print. Irving, Washington. The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon. Paris: Baudry’s European Library,
News. Gazetteer and New Daily Advertiser. 31 May 1765, Issue 11299. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. Gazetteer and New Daily Advertiser. 7 March 1766, Issue 11540. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. Gazetteer and New Daily Advertiser. 28 Oct. 1766, Issue 11746. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. George Faulkner the Dublin Journal. 26-30 Aug. 1746, Issue 2030. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. Lloyd's Evening Post and British Chronicle. 9-11 Nov. 1761, Issue 675. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. Lloyd's Evening Post and British Chronicle. 15-17 Feb. 1762, Issue 717. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. Lloyd's Evening Post. 4-6 Dec. 1765, Issue 1312. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. London Daily Advertiser. 6 April 1752, Issue 343. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. London Evening Post. 11-13 Feb. 1766, Issue 5966. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. North Briton (1769: Reprint). 12 Nov. 1763, Issue XLVI. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. News. Old Whig or The Consistent Protestant. 11 Aug. 1737, Issue 127. 17 th-18th^ Century Burney Collection Newspapers. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.