Comparison of Gravity Theories: Newtonian vs. Relativistic Frameworks, Slides of Physics

An overview of the key differences between newtonian and relativistic frameworks, specifically focusing on the concepts of rigid geometry, universal clocks, gravitational force, and interaction with distorted spacetime. It also discusses the scientific method and three 'classic' tests of general relativity, including the precession of mercury's orbit, deflection of starlight, and gravitational redshift.

Typology: Slides

2012/2013

Uploaded on 07/24/2013

bulla.baba
bulla.baba 🇮🇳

5

(7)

87 documents

1 / 21

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
Thereisabigdifferencebetweenthe
NewtonianandtheRelativisticframeworks:
Newtonian:
Rigid flat geometry, universal clocks
Gravitational force between objects
“Magic” dependence on mass
Relativistic:
Objects interact with
distorted spacetime
“Natural” reference frames
are in free fall
Docsity.com
pf3
pf4
pf5
pf8
pf9
pfa
pfd
pfe
pff
pf12
pf13
pf14
pf15

Partial preview of the text

Download Comparison of Gravity Theories: Newtonian vs. Relativistic Frameworks and more Slides Physics in PDF only on Docsity!

There^ is^ a^ big^ difference

between^ the

Newtonian^ and

the^ Relativistic

frameworks:

Newtonian:Rigid flat geometry, universal clocksGravitational force between objects“Magic” dependence on mass

Relativistic:Objects interact withdistorted spacetime“Natural” reference framesare in free fall Docsity.com

Is^ There^ a^ Real

(i.e.^ measurable)

Distinction

between^ General

Relativity^ and

the Newtonian^

Viewpoint?

-^ Absolutely! •^ Discriminating

among^ different

contending

theories^ is^ one

of^ the^ tasks^ of

experimental

physics. • Probing^ the^ basic

foundations^ of

gravity

continues^ to^ be

a^ forefront^ issue

-^ Was^ Einstein

Right^ by^ Clifford

Will^ is^ a^ nice

reference^ for^ this

topic...

The^3 “Classic”

Tests^ of^ General Relativity

-^ Precession^ of

Mercury’s^ orbit

-^ Deflection^ of

starlight^ (gravitational

lensing)

-^ Gravitational

Redshift

Precession

of^ Mercury’s

Orbit

Newtonian^

General Relativity

Deflection^

of^ Starlight

-^ Light^ is^ deflected

by gravitational field – called “gravitational^ lensing”

-^ Much^ like^ ball^ deflected

by divot

Deflection^

of^ Starlight

•^ During^ an^ eclipse,

the^ sky^ around

the^ sun^ is

dark^ enough^ to

see^ distant^ stars.

•^ Stars^ close^ to

the^ sun^ have^ their

light

deflected^ and^ so

appear^ at^ a^ shifted

position

(farther^ from^ sun) • Comparing^ stellar

locations^ with

and^ without

the^ presence^ of

the^ sun^ along^

the^ line^ of^ sight

allows^ for^ a^ measurement

of^ the^ deflection

of

light^ rays.

Deflection^ of

Starlight^ During

an Eclipse If deflection = 1.74 arcseconds

General Relativity Prediction If deflection = 0.87 arcseconds

Newtonian Prediction If deflection = 0.0 arcseconds

Both wrong!!

Seen at a distance of 4 km, a quarter (25 cents)spans about an arcsecond of angle

As^ GR^ predicts,

starlight^ is^ deflected

Improvements

over^ Time

Lunar^ Laser

Ranging • Can^ test^ Equivalence

Principle (universality^ of^ free

‐fall)^ by pinging^ moon^ with^

laser^ pulse

-^ GR^ relies^ completely

on^ this principle:^ accelerations independent^ of^ mass

gravity^ can be^ “fictitious”^ force • Test^ Earth^ and^ Moon

in^ free^ fall toward^ (around)^ Sun

Lunar^ Laser

Ranging,^ continued

-^ Precisely^ time^ round

‐trip^ light time^ to^ moon^ (2.5^ s) • Previous^ experiments

got^ 2– cm^ accuracy • APOLLO^ gets^1 mm^

accuracy

-^ Carefully^ measure

orbit^ and look for distortions^ or displacements not^ consistent with GR (^14) • One part in 10 precision!

Apollo 11 reflector array Apache Point Observatory 3.5 mtelescope (NM)

LIGO

LIGO is a pair of L-shaped laser interferometers (4 km vacuum pipe legs!),with one station in Hanford WA, and the other in Livingston LA.Could be the first to detect grav. waves as black holes inspiral and merge.http://www.ligo.caltech.edu/

LISA:^ A^ space

‐based^ grav.

wave observatory LISA is like a LIGO in space, with three legs, 5 million km long. Will see gravity waves full time, from many sources (a symphony of waves).Joint European/US project not yet fully funded

http://lisa.nasa.gov/