Understanding Valid & Sound Arguments: Truth-Functional Connectives & Conjunction, Study notes of Reasoning

The concepts of valid and sound arguments in philosophy, focusing on truth-functional connectives and conjunction. It provides definitions and examples to help understand how these concepts function in logical reasoning. Students of philosophy will find this document useful for studying arguments and their structure.

Typology: Study notes

Pre 2010

Uploaded on 08/09/2009

koofers-user-eun
koofers-user-eun 🇺🇸

10 documents

1 / 3

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
PHI 251
A valid argument:
(1) The conclusion follows from the premises.
(2) The premises conclusively support the conclusion.
(3) In every possible situation in which the premises are all true, the conclusion is
also true.
(4) It is impossible for the premises to be true with the conclusion false.
(5) If the premises were true, then the conclusion would be true.
A sound argument: The premises are true and the argument is valid.
Truth-functional connectives:
∇ΟΟ
TTT
TFF
FTF
FFF
Truth-functionally compound sentence: A compound sentence whose truth-
value depends upon the truth-values of its constituent sentences and not on
anything else.
Truth-functional connective: a connective symbol or word that is used to make
truth-functionally compound sentences.
Conjunction symbol:
pf3

Partial preview of the text

Download Understanding Valid & Sound Arguments: Truth-Functional Connectives & Conjunction and more Study notes Reasoning in PDF only on Docsity!

PHI 251

A valid argument: (1) The conclusion follows from the premises. (2) The premises conclusively support the conclusion. (3) In every possible situation in which the premises are all true, the conclusion is also true. (4) It is impossible for the premises to be true with the conclusion false. (5) If the premises were true, then the conclusion would be true.

A sound argument: The premises are true and the argument is valid.

Truth-functional connectives:

T T T

T F F

F T F

F F F

Truth-functionally compound sentence: A compound sentence whose truth- value depends upon the truth-values of its constituent sentences and not on anything else.

Truth-functional connective: a connective symbol or word that is used to make truth-functionally compound sentences.

Conjunction symbol:

Showing validity

Alicia is in my chemistry class • Bernard is in my chemistry class Therefore, Alicia is in my chemistry class.

conclusion premise A B A • B T T T F F T F F

Some words in English that can be represented by the conjunction symbol:

and, but, nevertheless, however, still, etc.

Negation: ~

T F

F T

Showing validity for a slightly more interesting argument

Alicia and Bernard are not both in my class. Alicia is in my class. So, Bernard is not in my class.

p2 p1 conclusion A B A • B ~ (A • B) ~ B T T T F F T F F