Reflective Writing: A Guide for Students, Lecture notes of Business

Reflective thinking can be applied to all aspects of your academic and professional lives. 1. What is reflection? 2. A model for writing reflectively. 3.

Typology: Lecture notes

2021/2022

Uploaded on 09/07/2022

zaafir_ij
zaafir_ij 🇦🇪

4.4

(61)

884 documents

1 / 2

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
Academic Skills Office (ASO)Fact Sheets
Reflective Writing
Reflection is an important part of learning and professional practice. For this reason, reflective
writing tasks may be set as an assessment in some of your units, particularly if you are studying
professional degrees in education, health, or business. But reflection is not only beneficial for these
disciplines. Reflective thinking can be applied to all aspects of your academic and professional lives.
1. What is reflection?
2. A model for writing reflectively
3. Different reflective assessment tasks
1. What is reflection?
Reflection involves examining your personal reactions and responses to your educational, research,
professional, or personal experiences. Through reflection activities, you have the opportunity to
identify and question your own thoughts or reactions to the theories, philosophies, and knowledge
by comparing them to your own past experiences. Conscious, purposeful, and critical reflection on
your actions, thoughts, and behaviours can consolidate your learning, transform your future
practice, and develop lifelong learning skills.
2. A model for writing reflectively
The 5Rs framework (Bain et al., 2002) provides a model that can help you to structure your
reflective writing. Each stage increases in the complexity and/or abstraction of information
required. Different tasks may require different levels of response.
Stage
Task
Useful language
Stage 1 Reporting
describe
a situation, incident, or issue
that you observed or were i nvolved in
What I did
e.g., I saw…, I witnessed…, I said…., I
heard
Where and when it took place
e.g., in a meeting, in
the classroom, during my first placement, on my last
day…
Stage 2
Responding
explain
your emotional or personal
response to that situation, incident, or
issue
What did I feel and
think
e.g., I felt…, I thought..., I
believe…, I think…, I remember…
How did I react to this situation
, e.g., distressed,
frustrated, impressed
Stage 3 Relating
relate
the situation, incident, or i ssue
to previous experiences or to other
knowledge that you have such as
theories or other relevant literature
Compare and
contrast
my responses
e.g., in the
same way, similarly, like, in contrast, al though
Provide evidence
e.g., this demonstrates that…,
Brown (2019) suggests that…
Stage 4
Reasoning
explore
the situation, incident, or issue
in more depth; look for explanations
for causes and effects; draw on
theories and other relevant sources
Think about cause and effect, reason, and result
e.g., because, as a result, consequently, therefore,
thus
Use references to sources
e.g., according to Dunn
(2020),…
Stage 5
Reconstructing
draw conclusions
about the situation,
incident, or issue based on the
understanding you have gai ned from
the reflective process;
plan
how you
might approach similar issues in the
future
Think about different impacts or alternative
outcomes
e.g., in these circumstances, teachers must
reflect…
How I may behave differently in the future
e.g., I
will…, Next time, I should …, children must be
encouraged to, they could have done
pf2

Partial preview of the text

Download Reflective Writing: A Guide for Students and more Lecture notes Business in PDF only on Docsity!

Academic Skills Office (ASO) – Fact Sheets

Reflective Writing

Reflection is an important part of learning and professional practice. For this reason, reflective

writing tasks may be set as an assessment in some of your units, particularly if you are studying

professional degrees in education, health, or business. But reflection is not only beneficial for these

disciplines. Reflective thinking can be applied to all aspects of your academic and professional lives.

1. What is reflection?

2. A model for writing reflectively

3. Different reflective assessment tasks

1. What is reflection?

Reflection involves examining your personal reactions and responses to your educational, research,

professional, or personal experiences. Through reflection activities, you have the opportunity to

identify and question your own thoughts or reactions to the theories, philosophies, and knowledge

by comparing them to your own past experiences. Conscious, purposeful, and critical reflection on

your actions, thoughts, and behaviours can consolidate your learning, transform your future

practice, and develop lifelong learning skills.

2. A model for writing reflectively

The 5Rs framework (Bain et al., 2002) provides a model that can help you to structure your

reflective writing. Each stage increases in the complexity and/or abstraction of information

required. Different tasks may require different levels of response.

Stage Task Useful language Stage 1 Reporting describe a situation, incident, or issue that you observed or were involved in

What I did e.g., I saw…, I witnessed…, I said…., I heard Where and when it took place e.g., in a meeting, in the classroom, during my first placement, on my last day…

Stage 2 Responding

explain your emotional or personal response to that situation, incident, or issue

What did I feel and think e.g., I felt…, I thought..., I believe…, I think…, I remember… How did I react to this situation , e.g., distressed, frustrated, impressed

Stage 3 Relating relate the situation, incident, or issue to previous experiences or to other knowledge that you have such as theories or other relevant literature

Compare and contrast my responses e.g., in the same way, similarly, like, in contrast, although Provide evidence e.g., this demonstrates that…, Brown (2019) suggests that…

Stage 4 Reasoning

explore the situation, incident, or issue in more depth; look for explanations for causes and effects; draw on theories and other relevant sources

Think about cause and effect, reason, and result e.g., because, as a result, consequently, therefore, thus Use references to sources e.g., according to Dunn (2020),…

Stage 5 Reconstructing

draw conclusions about the situation, incident, or issue based on the understanding you have gained from the reflective process; plan how you might approach similar issues in the future

Think about different impacts or alternative outcomes e.g., in these circumstances, teachers must reflect… How I may behave differently in the future e.g., I will…, Next time, I should …, children must be encouraged to…, they could have done…

Academic Skills Office (ASO) – Fact Sheets

3. Different reflective assessment tasks

There are different types of reflective tasks:

  • Journals record new experiences and ideas encountered in classrooms, research, or on work

placements. Note down how you feel about them and how they may challenge your existing

knowledge and understanding. Journals can be a private, personal record or set as an

assessment task. For assessment tasks, you should also refer to relevant literature to support

your ideas (i.e., references to authors of your information sources).

  • Critical reflection goes beyond description to consideration of the how and why of an event or

what a reading means and how it will impact on your understanding.

References Bain, J. D., Ballantyne, R., Mills, C., & Lester, N. C. (2002). Reflecting on practice: Student teachers’ perspectives. Post Pressed. Ryan, M. (2011). Improving reflective writing in higher education: A social semiotic perspective. Teaching in Higher Education, 16 (1), 99-

  1. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2010.

Example reflective journal (Ji Eun Lee, Nursing student )

Report the incident

Relate incident to evidence

Explain emotional response

Plan how to approach this issue

I met a patient with an eating disorder who was admitted to the paediatric ward in the hospital during my fourth placement. Her main problem was refusing to eat food, and also recently she disclosed that she heard voices saying that she needs to lose weight. Her speech was soft and passive, but also very adamant if I asked her to have a bit of food. Harken et al. (2017) find that adolescents with eating disorders can react in this way, so communication can be difficult. I felt like helping her in a warm manner using therapeutic communication that I’d learned, but I did not know where to start. She had a long history of mental health issues, and approaching her was not easy for me. I would like to improve my communication skills, so the first thing that I did was I observed how the nurses and doctor approached her, how they made a care plan for her, and what they thought the best care for her would be. I will start with general questions to stimulate her interests rather than thinking and questioning her too seriously. Because English is not my first language, watching Australian dramas might be helpful for me to understand the characteristics of Australians so I know what to expect from her and how to respond.

Example critical reflection paragraph (Education student)

Introduce topic or concept Report/respond to an incident

Relate incident to theory/evidence

Conclude by considering alternative practices to improve future practice

For learning to be successful, it must have a relevant contextual basis. In my observation of a lesson, I watched the teacher of a Year 5 class explain the concept of gravity to students. As I went around the classroom giving individual help to children, I discovered that most of them did not understand what she had taught them. They copied her explanation from the board, but they were not given the opportunity to experiment for themselves. Learning about the world through isolated facts and theories is not as conducive to genuine understanding as learning that is relevant to students’ lives and that involves participation in hands-on activities (Fitzgerald & Smith, 2016). This teacher could have devised a series of classroom experiments that investigated gravity, thus involving the children in hands-on experience. Alternatively, children could be asked to design their own experiments to encourage them to reflect, speculate, and explain, thus making their learning both authentic and relevant.