






Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
A comprehensive overview of key concepts in international law, including jurisdiction, immunities, and extradition. It explores the different types of jurisdiction, including territorial, nationality, and universal jurisdiction, and examines the principles of diplomatic and state immunity. The document also delves into the concept of extradition, highlighting its role in international cooperation and the balance between territorial jurisdiction and international justice. It concludes by discussing the act of state doctrine, a principle that limits the ability of one country's courts to question the official acts of another country's government.
Typology: Study notes
1 / 11
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!







PUBLIC INTERNATIONAL LAW LECTURE 5 UNITED NATIONS ORGANIZATION 1. Introduction The United Nations (UNO) is one of the most significant and influential international organizations established after World War II. It plays a pivotal role in maintaining international peace and security, promoting human rights, advancing social and economic cooperation, and coordinating international efforts to solve global challenges. In this lecture, we will examine the structure, functions, and legal framework of the UNO, and how it relates to public international law. 2. The Creation of the United Nations • Background and History: o The United Nations was founded in 1945 following the end of World War II, replacing the League of Nations, which had failed to prevent the outbreak of the war. o The creation of the UNO was aimed at preventing further global conflicts, promoting human rights, and advancing social and economic cooperation. o The Charter of the United Nations (UN Charter), adopted on June 26, 1945, in San Francisco, came into effect on October 24, 1945. This day is celebrated annually as United Nations Day. • Key Objectives: The main goals of the United Nations are: 1. To maintain international peace and security. 2. To develop friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples. 3. To achieve international cooperation in solving international problems of an economic, social, cultural, or humanitarian nature. 4. To be a center for harmonizing the actions of nations in achieving these common goals. 3. The Structure of the United Nations The United Nations consists of six principal organs, each of which has a specific role and function. These organs are: I. The General Assembly • Role: Composed of all 193 member states, the General Assembly is the primary deliberative and policymaking body. It meets annually to discuss a wide range of international issues, such as human rights, arms reduction, and the budget of the UNO. • Voting System: Each member state has one vote, and decisions on most issues require a two-thirds majority. • Powers: It can make recommendations on global issues, but it cannot enforce laws. II. The Security Council • Role: Responsible for maintaining international peace and security. It can impose sanctions, authorize the use of force, and take other measures to address threats to peace. • Composition: The Security Council consists of 15 members, including 5 permanent members (China, France, Russia, the UK, and the USA) and 10 elected non-permanent members. • Veto Power: The five permanent members have veto power, meaning any substantive decision requires their unanimous approval. III. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) • Role: The ICJ is the principal judicial organ of the UN. It settles legal disputes between states and gives advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it by the General Assembly, Security Council, or other UN organs. • Location: The ICJ is based in The Hague, Netherlands. • Jurisdiction: It has jurisdiction over disputes between states that have consented to its authority. IV. The Secretariat • Role: The Secretariat carries out the day-to-day work of the United Nations. It is responsible for implementing the decisions of the General Assembly, Security Council, and other bodies. • Headed by: The Secretary-General, who is appointed by the General Assembly on the recommendation of the Security Council. The Secretary-General plays a critical diplomatic role in peacekeeping and conflict resolution. V. The Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) • Role: ECOSOC coordinates the economic, social, and related work of 15 specialized agencies, including the World Health Organization (WHO), UNESCO, and the International Labour Organization (ILO). • Focus: Promotes international economic cooperation and development, addressing issues such as poverty, education, health, and human rights. VI. The Trusteeship Council • Role: Initially created to oversee the administration of trust territories and guide them to self-government, the Trusteeship Council has largely completed its mandate. Its activities are now dormant since all trust territories have achieved self-governance. 4. The Legal Framework of the United Nations The UN operates within the framework of the UN Charter, which is a multilateral treaty that sets out the rights and obligations of member states. The Charter is considered the constitution of the United Nations. • Key Provisions of the UN Charter: 1. Article 2(4) prohibits the threat or use of force in international relations, except in cases of self-defense. 2. Article 51 allows for the right of self-defense if an armed
attack occurs. 3. Article 25 binds member states to accept and carry out decisions of the Security Council. 4. Article 103 makes clear that the UN Charter supersedes other international agreements, giving precedence to its provisions. 5. The United Nations and Public International Law The United Nations plays a central role in the development and enforcement of public international law. Some important areas where the UNO contributes include: I. Human Rights The UN has created key instruments like the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) and treaties such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). These documents set the international legal standards for human rights protections. II. Peace and Security The Security Council can take action to prevent conflict, intervene in ongoing conflicts, and help rebuild societies after war. The Security Council’s resolutions are binding on member states, and it is authorized to use force in response to threats to international peace and security. III. Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development Through frameworks such as the Paris Agreement (2015) and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), the UN has facilitated international cooperation on environmental law and global sustainability. IV. International Humanitarian Law (IHL) The UN plays a significant role in promoting IHL, particularly through the Geneva Conventions and the International Criminal Court (ICC), which deals with war crimes and crimes against humanity. 6. Criticism and Challenges Facing the UN Despite its achievements, the United Nations faces significant criticism and challenges: 1. Veto Power in the Security Council: The veto power of the five permanent members has led to paralysis in decision-making, especially in situations where global consensus is needed but blocked by one or more of the permanent members (e.g., Syria, Ukraine). 2. Inefficiency in Peacekeeping Operations: The UN has been criticized for its inability to effectively manage peacekeeping missions, with instances of peacekeepers being accused of misconduct or failing to protect civilians during conflicts. 3. Lack of Representation: Some critics argue that the UN does not adequately represent the current global political order, with countries like India, Germany, Brazil, and others pushing for permanent membership in the Security Council. 4. Financial Issues: The UN is often criticized for its dependence on a few powerful states for funding, which can influence its priorities and policies. 7. The Role of Pakistan in the United Nations As a member of the United Nations, Pakistan plays an active role in various UN bodies. Some key contributions include: • Peacekeeping Missions: Pakistan has contributed significantly to UN peacekeeping efforts, with Pakistani soldiers serving in conflict zones such as Congo, Lebanon, and Sierra Leone. • Human Rights Advocacy: Pakistan has been an advocate for the rights of developing nations, including promoting the right to self-determination, particularly in Kashmir. • Security Council Membership: Pakistan has served as a non-permanent member of the UN Security Council multiple times and has contributed to discussions on peace and security issues in South Asia and beyond. Conclusion The United Nations is a cornerstone of modern international law and global diplomacy. It provides a platform for states to cooperate, resolve disputes, and address international issues. However, challenges such as political power dynamics, inefficiency, and financial constraints continue to impact the effectiveness of the UN. Understanding the UN’s role is crucial for students of public international law, as it shapes the legal norms that govern the relations between states and global citizens.
universal jurisdiction for such crimes. 2. Piracy: A pirate, irrespective of nationality, can be prosecuted by any state that captures the individual, due to piracy’s status as a universally condemned act under international law. Case Law Example: • The Pinochet Case (1998) – UK House of Lords: o Facts: Former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet was arrested in London on charges of torture and crimes against humanity. o Issue: Could Pinochet be extradited to Spain to face charges despite his claims of immunity as a former head of state? o Ruling: The House of Lords ruled that universal jurisdiction applied to acts of torture and that Pinochet was not immune from prosecution.
for crimes committed under the laws of the requesting state. Extradition operates as a mechanism of cooperation between states to combat cross-border crime and uphold justice. Key Principles of Extradition 1. Dual Criminality: o The crime for which extradition is sought must be considered a punishable offense under the laws of both the requesting and requested states. o Example: If theft is a criminal offense in both countries, extradition can proceed. However, if an act is criminal in one country but not in the other (e.g., blasphemy in some states but not others), extradition may be denied. 2. Specialty Principle: o The individual extradited can only be tried or punished for the specific offense for which extradition was granted. They cannot be prosecuted for unrelated crimes committed prior to extradition unless the requested state consents. 3. Non-Extradition for Political Offenses: o Many treaties and laws prohibit extradition for purely political offenses, such as sedition or treason, to avoid persecution under politically motivated charges. 4. Human Rights Considerations: o A state may refuse extradition if there is a risk that the individual will face torture, inhumane treatment, or a lack of fair trial in the requesting state. This principle is enshrined in international human rights law, including the United Nations Convention Against Torture. 5. Extradition Treaties: o Extradition is usually governed by bilateral or multilateral treaties. In the absence of a treaty, states may still extradite based on diplomatic agreements or principles of reciprocity. Procedure for Extradition 1. Request for Extradition: o The requesting state submits a formal extradition request, typically through diplomatic channels, to the requested state. 2. Judicial Review: o Courts in the requested state review the extradition request to ensure it complies with the conditions of applicable treaties and domestic laws. o The review may include assessing dual criminality, specialty, and human rights implications. 3. Executive Decision: o Once judicial approval is granted, the executive branch (e.g., the government or president) makes the final decision to surrender the individual. Examples of Extradition in Practice 1. Edward Snowden Case (2013): o Facts: Snowden, a former U.S. intelligence contractor, fled to Russia after leaking classified information about U.S. surveillance programs. o Outcome: The U.S. requested his extradition, but Russia declined, citing the political nature of the charges and granting him asylum. 2. Julian Assange Case (Ongoing): o Facts: Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, was charged by the U.S. with espionage- related offenses. He sought asylum in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London to avoid extradition. o Outcome: After his asylum was revoked, the U.K. arrested him. The extradition process to the U.S. is still being litigated. 3. Abu Salem Case (2005): o Facts: Abu Salem, an Indian fugitive, was extradited from Portugal to India for his alleged involvement in the 1993 Mumbai bombings. o Outcome: The extradition was granted after India assured Portugal that Salem would not face the death penalty, respecting Portugal's human rights laws. Territorial Jurisdiction in Extradition In the context of territorial jurisdiction, extradition often involves crimes committed within the territorial jurisdiction of the requesting state: 1. Crime in Requesting State's Territory: o A state may seek extradition for an offense committed on its soil, even if the accused flees to another country. o Example: A person commits murder in Country A and escapes to Country B. Country A can request extradition to prosecute the crime committed within its territorial jurisdiction. 2. Cross-Border Crimes: o In cases of cross-border crimes like terrorism, cybercrime, or trafficking, the requesting state claims territorial jurisdiction over the acts that occurred within its borders. o Example: A hacker operating from Country X launches a cyber-attack on servers in Country Y. Country Y can request extradition based on the damage caused within its territory. Case Law Examples 1. Soering v. United Kingdom (1989) – European Court of Human Rights (ECHR): o Facts: Jens Soering, a German national, faced extradition from the UK to the U.S. on charges of murder, where he risked the death penalty. o Ruling: The ECHR held that extraditing Soering would violate Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights due to the inhumane conditions on death row in the U.S. This case established human rights as a critical factor in extradition decisions. 2. United States v. Alvarez-Machain (1992) – U.S. Supreme Court: o Facts: Alvarez-Machain, a Mexican citizen, was abducted by U.S. agents and brought to the
harmed or threatened in their own country. It’s like saying, “Come here; we’ll keep you safe.” Why Do People Seek Asylum? People run to another country because they are being treated unfairly or are in danger at home. This could be due to: Persecution for their religion, race, political beliefs, or being part of a certain group. War or violence in their home country. How Does It Work? 1. The Person Applies: They ask another country for asylum, saying they cannot go back home because it’s too dangerous. 2. The Country Decides: The country reviews their case. If it believes the person is really in danger, they will grant asylum. 3. Protection Given: If asylum is granted, the person can stay in the new country and is protected from being sent back to their own country. Example: Afghan Refugees in Pakistan 1. Background: o During the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan (1979–1989) and subsequent conflicts, millions of Afghans fled their country to escape violence and persecution. o Pakistan provided asylum to these refugees, hosting one of the largest refugee populations in the world. 2. Protection: o Refugees were housed in camps, primarily in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan provinces. o The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) worked with Pakistan to register and support these refugees. 3. Challenges: o The presence of Afghan refugees created economic, social, and security challenges for Pakistan. o Even after decades, many refugees remained in Pakistan, leading to debates about repatriation and integration. 4. Legal Framework: o Pakistan is not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention but has largely followed humanitarian practices in handling refugee crises. 3. ACT OF STATE DOCTRINE: The Act of State Doctrine is a principle in international law that says one country’s courts cannot question or challenge the official acts of another country’s government when those acts are done within the foreign country's own territory. What it Means: If a government does something in its own country (like passing laws, seizing property, or nationalizing industries), other countries’ courts won’t interfere or judge whether that act was right or wrong. Why It Exists: To respect the sovereignty of other nations and To avoid conflicts between governments. When It Applies: It applies only to official acts of a state, done by its government or authorities and These acts must occur within that state’s borders. A Real- Life Example: A real-life example of the Act of State Doctrine related to Pakistan can be found in cases involving government decisions on nationalization during the 1970s. Example: Nationalization of Industries in Pakistan (1972-1974) During the early 1970s, under Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the Government of Pakistan implemented a policy of nationalizing major industries, banks, and educational institutions. These actions were done as part of economic reforms aimed at redistributing wealth and improving social equality. Context: Foreign investors, as well as local private owners, were affected by the nationalization policies. Some foreign companies and individuals tried to challenge these actions in courts outside Pakistan, arguing that their properties were unfairly taken. Application of the Act of State Doctrine: Courts in other countries (e.g., the UK or the US) dismissed these cases, stating that they could not question the sovereign acts of the Pakistani government, as these acts were carried out within Pakistan’s own territory and under its laws. The doctrine was applied to respect Pakistan’s sovereignty and its right to make decisions about its internal economic policies. 4. RESPONSIBILITY TO PROTECT (R2P): Responsibility to Protect (R2P) is an international principle that says every country has a responsibility to protect its people from serious crimes, such as: 1. Genocide: Killing people because of their race, religion, or ethnicity.
or situations like the 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War. 1. 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War: o The military operation, known as Operation Searchlight, targeted Bengali civilians in East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). o It involved large-scale killings, rapes, and other atrocities that could be classified as crimes against humanity. o The international community criticized the Pakistani government for these actions. o If R2P had existed then, countries could have argued for intervention to protect the Bengali population. 2. Current Context - Balochistan: o Allegations of human rights violations, enforced disappearances, and military operations in Balochistan have raised concerns. o If these situations escalate into mass atrocities, R2P principles suggest that either Pakistan should address the issue or the international community may feel compelled to intervene diplomatically. R2P IS IMPORTANT because it reminds governments that their primary job is to protect their people. When they fail, the world has a responsibility to ensure that no community faces atrocities unchecked. However, it requires balancing sovereignty with the need for intervention, which is often controversial. 5. OCCUPATION IN INTERNATIONAL LAW: Occupation occurs when one state or military force takes control of another state’s territory without claiming sovereignty. The occupying power temporarily administers the area but does not have legal ownership of it. This happens mostly during wars or armed conflicts. Key Features of Occupation 1. Temporary Control: The occupying state controls the territory for a limited period. 2. No Sovereignty: The occupying power does not gain legal ownership of the territory. 3. Obligations of the Occupying Power: International law (e.g., the Fourth Geneva Convention) requires the occupier to protect civilians, respect laws in place, and ensure basic needs like food, medical care, and safety. Real-Life Example: Israel and Palestine Context: o After the 1967 Six-Day War, Israel occupied the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip, which were Palestinian territories. o This occupation continues, and Israel administers the area without claiming full sovereignty over it. Why It’s an Occupation: o Israel controls the territory militarily and politically, but the areas are not officially part of Israel under international law. o International law holds Israel responsible for ensuring basic rights and living conditions of the Palestinian population in the occupied areas. 6. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (IMF) The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is a global financial institution established in 1944 at the Bretton Woods Conference to ensure the stability of the international monetary system. Its primary goals are to foster global economic stability, facilitate trade, reduce poverty, and promote high employment and sustainable growth. Key Features 1. Headquarters: Washington, D.C., United States. 2. Membership: 190 member countries as of 2024. 3. Primary Functions: o Surveillance: Monitoring economic and financial developments of member countries. o Financial Assistance: Providing loans to countries facing balance of payments problems. o Capacity Development: Offering technical assistance and training to member states. Objectives 1. Promote international monetary cooperation. 2. Facilitate balanced growth of global trade. 3. Ensure exchange rate stability. 4. Provide resources to member countries during financial crises. Operations 1. Lending: o The IMF offers financial assistance to countries experiencing economic crises. o Loans come with conditionalities, requiring countries to implement policy reforms (e.g., fiscal austerity, privatization). o Common programs include Stand-By Arrangements (SBA) and Extended Fund Facility (EFF). 2. Surveillance: o The IMF conducts periodic reviews of member countries' economic policies. o Publishes reports like the World Economic Outlook and Global Financial Stability Report. 3. Capacity Development: o Provides training and technical expertise on public finance, monetary policy, and economic governance. 7. INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL POLICE ORGANIZATION (INTERPOL) Interpol, short for the International Criminal Police Organization, is an international organization that facilitates cooperation between police forces across the world. Established in 1923, its primary aim is to combat transnational crime and enhance global security. Key Features 1. Headquarters: Lyon, France. 2. Membership: 195 member countries. 3. Role: Assists law enforcement agencies in member countries to share intelligence and collaborate on criminal investigations. Objectives 1.
campaigns, and training healthcare workers to reach remote areas. 3. UNITED NATIONS HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR REFUGEES (UNHCR): The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), established in 1950, is dedicated to protecting and assisting refugees, stateless persons, and displaced communities. Its primary goal is to ensure the rights and well-being of individuals forced to flee their homes due to conflict, persecution, or natural disasters. Key Functions of UNHCR:
Article 1: "All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights." • Article 3: "Everyone has the right to life, liberty, and security of person." • Article 19: "Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression." • Article 21: "Everyone has the right to take part in the government of his country, directly or through freely chosen representatives." 6. WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (WHO): The World Health Organization (WHO) is a specialized agency of the United Nations responsible for international public health. Established on April 7, 1948, its headquarters are in Geneva, Switzerland. WHO’s primary mission is to promote health, keep the world safe, and serve the vulnerable. Key Functions of WHO: 1. Global Health Leadership: • WHO provides leadership on global health matters and ensures coordinated responses to public health emergencies, such as pandemics. 2. Setting Health Standards: • It develops international health standards, guidelines, and protocols to ensure consistent and effective healthcare practices worldwide. 3. Disease Control and Eradication: • WHO works to prevent, control, and eradicate diseases such as polio, malaria, HIV/AIDS, and tuberculosis. It played a significant role in eradicating smallpox. 4. Health Research: • WHO conducts research on health trends, diseases, and innovative treatments. It provides evidence- based recommendations for healthcare policies. 5. Health Systems Support: • It supports countries in building robust healthcare systems, training healthcare workers, and improving access to essential medical services. 6. Emergency Response: • WHO responds to health emergencies, including natural disasters, outbreaks, and conflicts, providing technical expertise and resources. 7. Promoting Public Health Awareness: • It runs global health campaigns on issues like mental health, immunization, tobacco control, and nutrition. Key Areas of Focus: 1. Universal Health Coverage: o Ensuring that everyone, everywhere, has access to quality healthcare without financial hardship. 2. Health Emergencies: o Preparing for and responding to global health emergencies such as pandemics (e.g., COVID-19). 3. Promoting Health and Well-being: o Addressing social determinants of health, improving maternal and child health, and combating noncommunicable diseases (e.g., diabetes, cancer). 4. Vaccination and Immunization: o Coordinating large-scale immunization efforts to protect populations from preventable diseases like measles and influenza. Notable Achievements: 1. Smallpox Eradication: • WHO led the campaign to eradicate smallpox, declared eradicated in 1980.