Comparing Davis & Another City: Analyzing Biking to Work with U.S. Census Data - Prof. Sus, Papers of Environmental Science

Instructions for accessing and analyzing u.s. Census data using american factfinder to compare levels of biking to work in davis with another city. The exercise involves selecting relevant tables, calculating percentages and medians, creating comparison tables, and generating graphs. Additionally, students are encouraged to compare their census tract within davis to the city as a whole and create thematic maps.

Typology: Papers

Pre 2010

Uploaded on 09/17/2009

koofers-user-y2c
koofers-user-y2c 🇺🇸

10 documents

1 / 2

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
ESP 178 Applied Research Methods
3/6 Exercise: Using U.S. Census Data
Background
The Census provides data that we can use to look at our question about biking in Davis. On the long form of
the census is a question that asks, “How did this person usually get to work last week?” One of the response
categories is, of course, “Bicycle.” We can use these results to compare levels of biking in Davis to other cities
and to look at differences in socio-economic characteristics that might explain differences in biking. For this
exercise, use your own home town or some other city of your choice (Palo Alto might be a fun one, or Eugene,
OR or Boulder, CO) as a comparison for Davis.
Steps
1. Find the web site for American FactFinder, the Census Bureau’s data access system: click on
http://www.census.gov/, then look for American FactFinder in the menu on the left.
2. Look for the Data Sets button in the menu on the left. In the Data Sets section, choose “Decennial Census.”
You should be on the tab for Census 2000 and you’ll see a tab for Census 1990 also. Check the button for
“Census 2000 Summary File 3” (this file includes the long-form data, downtown to the block group level).
From the various options, pick “Detailed Tables.” We’ll be selecting two geographic areas – the City of
Davis and the other city you picked. First add the city to your list by choosing “place” for “Select a
geographic type.” The pick “California” for “Select a state.” Then find Davis in the list of cities and click
“add.” Find your other city in the list (or go back and select a different state and then find your city) and
click “add” again. When you’ve got both cities in your list, click on “next.”
3. Now you’ll see a list of all of the tables available to you. Scroll through this list to find P30 “Means of
Transportation to Work for Workers 16+ years” and click “add.” Go back through the list of tables and
select five more that show characteristics that you think might be linked to levels of biking, adding them to
the list as you go. This will be harder than you think. The list is really, really long (many of the tables
provide “crosstabs” of two or more variables (e.g. age by sex) or may report numbers for one particular
segment of the population) and even for seemingly basic variables, you may have more than one option
(esp. race, ethnicity, income). Once you’ve got your list, then click “show result” and see what you get. If
you don’t like what came up, go back and revise the list of tables. Note: for median age, you need to go to
SF 1: on the line that says “you are here,” click on “data sets with detailed tables,” then find SF 1 in the list
of tables.
4. When you’re done, download your tables (look for the “Print/Download” tab at the top of the page),
checking the button for the “tab delimited” format (do not use the Excel spreadsheet option). Note: if you
hear a “beep” when you try to download the table, look at the line below the address line; click for options,
then select “Download File.” Now go back to the “Print/Download” tab and select “Download.” This time
it will work. Pick the “open” file option.
5. Construct a table that compares Davis to your other city. If your downloaded file is not already open, open
up Excel, then open your downloaded tables (when you open the file, just click through any windows that
pop up – “next,” “next,” “finish”). You will have to do a little clean-up formatting, such as changing
column widths. Once that’s done, you’re ready to create your comparison table. I suggest inserting some
rows at the top of the spreadsheet to make space for your table. The table should have three columns: one
for the variable labels, one for Davis, and one for the other city. Think through what variables and what
measures for those variables you want to show. Raw numbers rarely make for good comparisons, because
population totals are so different between cities. Instead, you’ll want to show percentages and medians or
pf2

Partial preview of the text

Download Comparing Davis & Another City: Analyzing Biking to Work with U.S. Census Data - Prof. Sus and more Papers Environmental Science in PDF only on Docsity!

ESP 178 Applied Research Methods

3/6 Exercise: Using U.S. Census Data

Background The Census provides data that we can use to look at our question about biking in Davis. On the long form of the census is a question that asks, “How did this person usually get to work last week?” One of the response categories is, of course, “Bicycle.” We can use these results to compare levels of biking in Davis to other cities and to look at differences in socio-economic characteristics that might explain differences in biking. For this exercise, use your own home town or some other city of your choice (Palo Alto might be a fun one, or Eugene, OR or Boulder, CO) as a comparison for Davis.

Steps

  1. Find the web site for American FactFinder, the Census Bureau’s data access system: click on http://www.census.gov/, then look for American FactFinder in the menu on the left.
  2. Look for the Data Sets button in the menu on the left. In the Data Sets section, choose “Decennial Census.” You should be on the tab for Census 2000 and you’ll see a tab for Census 1990 also. Check the button for “Census 2000 Summary File 3” (this file includes the long-form data, downtown to the block group level). From the various options, pick “Detailed Tables.” We’ll be selecting two geographic areas – the City of Davis and the other city you picked. First add the city to your list by choosing “place” for “Select a geographic type.” The pick “California” for “Select a state.” Then find Davis in the list of cities and click “add.” Find your other city in the list (or go back and select a different state and then find your city) and click “add” again. When you’ve got both cities in your list, click on “next.”
  3. Now you’ll see a list of all of the tables available to you. Scroll through this list to find P30 “Means of Transportation to Work for Workers 16+ years” and click “add.” Go back through the list of tables and select five more that show characteristics that you think might be linked to levels of biking, adding them to the list as you go. This will be harder than you think. The list is really, really long (many of the tables provide “crosstabs” of two or more variables (e.g. age by sex) or may report numbers for one particular segment of the population) and even for seemingly basic variables, you may have more than one option (esp. race, ethnicity, income). Once you’ve got your list, then click “show result” and see what you get. If you don’t like what came up, go back and revise the list of tables. Note: for median age, you need to go to SF 1: on the line that says “you are here,” click on “data sets with detailed tables,” then find SF 1 in the list of tables.
  4. When you’re done, download your tables (look for the “Print/Download” tab at the top of the page), checking the button for the “tab delimited” format (do not use the Excel spreadsheet option). Note: if you hear a “beep” when you try to download the table, look at the line below the address line; click for options, then select “Download File.” Now go back to the “Print/Download” tab and select “Download.” This time it will work. Pick the “open” file option.
  5. Construct a table that compares Davis to your other city. If your downloaded file is not already open, open up Excel, then open your downloaded tables (when you open the file, just click through any windows that pop up – “next,” “next,” “finish”). You will have to do a little clean-up formatting, such as changing column widths. Once that’s done, you’re ready to create your comparison table. I suggest inserting some rows at the top of the spreadsheet to make space for your table. The table should have three columns: one for the variable labels, one for Davis, and one for the other city. Think through what variables and what measures for those variables you want to show. Raw numbers rarely make for good comparisons, because population totals are so different between cities. Instead, you’ll want to show percentages and medians or

means. That means you need to use the raw data from your tables to calculate these measures. For example, to get “percent non-white,” you have to add up the total number of non-white residents and then divide by the total number of residents. You get the idea. If you’ve got a little extra time, work on the format of your table to get it into shape for public consumption.

Here’s a good format for your table:

Comparison of Davis and Palo Alto Davis Palo Alto Percent Bicycled to Work

Total Population Percent Non-White Percent With Commute Time under 15 minutes Median Age Median household income in 1999 Source: 2000 U.S. Census, SF 1 and SF 3

  1. Now try comparing your census tract within Davis to the city as a whole. To find your census tract, go back to the main American FactFinder page, click on “maps” in the menu on the leftside of the page, then click on “reference maps.” Select 2000 Census Tracts, and enter your zip code. A map will now appear. Zoom in until you can see your neighborhood. Census tracts are outlined in orange, and the number will look something like “105.10.” Now go back to the SF 3 file and for type of geography indicate “census tract”, then California, then Yolo County, then find your census tract number. Once you’ve done that, find tables, etc.
  2. Make a graph or two from your data to compare the two cities on one or two key characteristics and/or to compare your census tract to the city.
  3. Write a brief (half-page double-spaced) memo that summarizes your data analysis. Paste your table and graphs into the memo.
  4. MAPPING BONUS: Now let’s find a map that shows share of residents commuting by transit in Davis neighborhoods. Look for “Maps” in the menu on the left side of the main American FactFinder page, then click on “Thematic Maps.” To choose a dataset, click on “Data Sets with Thematic Maps” at the top of the frame, then choose “Census 2000 Summary File 3 (SF 3) Sample Data” and click “next”. Under “Select a geographic type” pick “Place”, then “California”, then “Davis city”, then “Next.” Scroll through the list of themes until you find “TM-P038 Percent of Workers 16 and Over Who Commute to Work by Public Transportation: 2000”. Click on “Show result.” How does your neighborhood compare to others? Does the pattern make sense for the city? At the top of the map, change “Display map by:” from census tract to block group. How does your neighborhood compare now? Report the results in your memo. Try mapping other themes if you have time (shortcut: click on “themes” in the line under “Thematic Maps” near the top of the page; try ).
  5. Send your memo to Tuyeni via email ([email protected]) and save it on your USB drive or email it to yourself.

Note: If you want to know how a particular measure is defined, check Appendix B (definitions) or Appendix D (questionnaire) of the Technical Documentation for STF1 or STF3.

Note: The Census Bureau now collects population data on an on-going basis in the American Community Survey. The sample sizes are much smaller, however, and there are no data for Davis at this point.