Download Appeals BNSS handwritten notes and more Study notes Law in PDF only on Docsity!
Appeals Section 413 to 435 Section 413 BNSS – No Appeal to Lie Unless Otherwise Provided (The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) Simple Meaning of Section 413 This section means that a person cannot file an appeal against every criminal court judgment or order automatically. An appeal is possible only when: the BNSS specifically allows it, or some other law allows it. In simple words, appeal is a legal right created by law, not an automatic right in every case. Easy Human Explanation Suppose a criminal court gives a judgment. A person may feel the decision is wrong and want to challenge it in a higher court. But Section 413 says:
“You can challenge the decision only if the law gives you the right to appeal.” So, if the BNSS or another law does not provide an appeal, then no appeal can be filed. Important Part – Rights of the Victim This section specially protects victims. A victim has the right to file an appeal if: the accused is acquitted (found not guilty), or the accused is convicted for a lesser offence, or the court gives inadequate compensation. What is “Lesser Offence”? Sometimes the court may convict a person for a smaller offence instead of the serious offence originally charged. Example: A person is charged with attempt to murder. But the court convicts him only for causing simple hurt. The victim may feel justice was not properly done.
Section 414 BNSS – Appeal from Orders Requiring Security or Refusal to Accept Surety for Keeping Peace or Good Behaviour (The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) Simple Meaning of Section 414 This section gives a person the right to appeal when: The court orders him to furnish security for keeping peace or good behaviour under Section 136, or The court refuses to accept or rejects his surety under Section 140. The appeal can be filed before the Sessions Court. Easy Human Explanation Sometimes a Magistrate believes that a person may: Disturb public peace, Create violence, Or behave dangerously. In such cases, the Magistrate may order that person to: Execute a bond,
Provide security, Or bring sureties (guarantors) to ensure good behaviour. If the person feels the order is unfair, Section 414 allows him to challenge it before the Sessions Court. What is “Security for Keeping Peace”? It means a person gives a legal promise that: He will maintain peace, Not create trouble, And follow lawful behaviour. The court may also ask for money bonds or sureties. What is a “Surety”? A surety is a person who guarantees before the court that the accused/person will behave properly. If the person breaks the conditions, the surety may lose the bond amount. When Can Appeal Be Filed? An appeal can be filed in two situations:
- Order to Give Security under Section 136
This section does not apply when proceedings are directly placed before a Sessions Judge under Section 141(2) or Section 141(4). In such cases, appeal under Section 414 is not available because the matter is already before a higher court. Section 415 BNSS – Appeals from Convictions (The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) Simple Meaning of Section 415 This section explains: who can file an appeal after conviction, and which higher court will hear that appeal. The court where the appeal goes depends on: which court gave the conviction, and the seriousness of the punishment. Easy Human Explanation When a person is convicted in a criminal case, he may believe:
the judgment is wrong, evidence was misunderstood, punishment is too harsh, or the trial was unfair. Section 415 gives such person the right to challenge the conviction before a higher court. Appeals Under Different Situations
- Appeal from High Court Trial → Supreme Court If a person is convicted in a trial conducted by the High Court under its extraordinary original criminal jurisdiction, he can appeal to the Supreme Court. Example: The High Court directly conducts a criminal trial and convicts a person. That person can appeal before the Supreme Court.
- Appeal to High Court A person can appeal to the High Court if: he was convicted by a Sessions Judge or Additional Sessions Judge, or
Example: A Judicial Magistrate convicts Seema and gives 2 years imprisonment. Seema can appeal before the Sessions Court. Important Provision – Time Limit for Certain Appeals Sub-section (4) says that appeals relating to offences under Sections 64 to 71 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 must be decided within six months. These sections mainly relate to serious offences against women. Purpose of Fast Disposal The law wants speedy justice in sensitive criminal cases. Therefore, appeals in such offences should not remain pending for years. Section 416 BNSS – No Appeal in Certain Cases When Accused Pleads Guilty (The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023)
Simple Meaning of Section 416 This section says that when an accused person voluntarily pleads guilty and is convicted on that plea, generally no appeal can be filed against the conviction. However, the accused can still challenge: The legality of the sentence, or The extent (severity) of the punishment. Easy Human Explanation If a person himself admits before the court that he committed the offence, then the law usually does not allow him to later challenge the conviction. Why? Because the conviction is based on his own admission. But if the punishment given is: Illegal, Excessive, Or not according to law,
Exception – Appeal Regarding Sentence Even after pleading guilty, the accused may appeal regarding:
- Extent of Sentence If punishment is too harsh or excessive. Example: A person pleads guilty to a minor offence, but the court gives maximum punishment without proper reason. He may appeal for reduction of sentence.
- Legality of Sentence If punishment is illegal or not authorised by law. Example: Law allows maximum imprisonment of 2 years, but court mistakenly gives 5 years. The accused can challenge the legality of the sentence. Section 417 BNSS – No Appeal in Petty Cases
(The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) Simple Meaning of Section 417 This section says that in very minor criminal cases, a convicted person cannot file an appeal if the punishment is very small. The law treats such cases as “petty cases” to avoid unnecessary burden on higher courts. Easy Human Explanation Sometimes courts give very small punishments like: Short imprisonment, Small fines, Or both. In such minor matters, the law says: “A regular appeal should not be allowed.” This helps courts save time and focus on serious criminal cases. Cases Where No Appeal is Allowed A.Conviction by High Court No appeal lies if the High Court gives only:
C. Conviction by Magistrate First Class No appeal lies if the Magistrate First Class gives only: Fine up to ₹100. Example: Magistrate imposes ₹80 fine for a minor offence. No appeal can be filed. D. Summary Trial Cases In summary trials under Section 283, if the Magistrate gives only: Fine up to ₹200, Then no appeal lies. What is a Summary Trial? A summary trial is a fast and simplified procedure used for minor offences. Important Exception – When Appeal is Allowed Appeal can still be filed if some other punishment is added along with the petty punishment. Example:
A court gives: ₹100 fine, and Cancellation of licence. Now appeal may be allowed because an additional punishment is involved. Situations Which DO NOT Create Right of Appeal The following situations alone do not make the case appealable:
- Order to Furnish Security If the person is ordered to maintain peace/security, appeal is still barred.
- Imprisonment for Non-payment of Fine If court says: “Pay fine or go to jail,” That does not create a right of appeal.
- Multiple Small Fines If several fines together still remain within the legal limit, appeal is not allowed.
In such cases, Section 418 allows the State Government or Central Government to challenge the sentence. What is “Inadequate Sentence”? An inadequate sentence means punishment that is too lenient compared to the seriousness of the offence. Example: A person commits a serious violent offence, but the court gives only a very small punishment. The Government may appeal asking the higher court to increase the sentence. Who Can File the Appeal?
- State Government The State Government may direct the Public Prosecutor to file appeal when conviction is by any court other than the High Court. Where Will the Appeal Go? If sentence is passed by Magistrate:
→ Appeal goes to the Sessions Court. If sentence is passed by any other court: → Appeal goes to the High Court. Example: A Magistrate convicts an accused for assault and gives only a nominal sentence. The State Government may appeal before the Sessions Court seeking enhancement of punishment.
- Central Government The Central Government may also file appeal if: The offence was investigated by a central investigating agency under a Central Act. Example of Central Agencies Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) Enforcement Directorate (ED) Example: CBI investigates a corruption case.
