Audit report template, Exercises of Engineering

The objective of the audit was to determine that all planned elements1 of the management system(s), relevant to the scope of.

Typology: Exercises

2021/2022

Uploaded on 09/12/2022

arwen
arwen šŸ‡¬šŸ‡§

4.3

(10)

248 documents

1 / 9

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
ECF045-1a(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 1 | P a g e
Audit Report
Of organization:
INSTITUT TEKNOLOGI NASIONAL MALANG
Client number: QU160232
Report Author: Rudy Wijaya
Visit date: August 28-29, 2017
Visit duration 6.0 onsite + 0 desktop (man-day)
pf3
pf4
pf5
pf8
pf9

Partial preview of the text

Download Audit report template and more Exercises Engineering in PDF only on Docsity!

ECF045-1a(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 1 | P a g e

Of organization:

INSTITUT TEKNOLOGI NASIONAL MALANG

Client number: QU

Report Author: Rudy Wijaya

Visit date: August 28-29, 2017

Visit duration 6.0 onsite + 0 desktop (man-day)

ECF045-1b(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 2 |

Audit objectives

The objective of the audit was to determine that all planned elements^1 of the management system(s), relevant to the scope of certification, at the sites specified, are effectively addressed by the organisation. These are detailed in the following table:

Visit type Certification standard(s) Level of integration

Certification Number

Surveillance Audit ISO 9001:2008 N/A NA QU N/A N/A Certification scope: Provision of Higher Education Including Faculty of Civil Engineering and Planning ( such as : Civil Engineering , Architecture , Geodesy Engineering , Environmental Engineering , Urban and Regional Planning , Civil -Structure Engineering (Diploma)) and Faculty of Industrial Technology ( Such as : Mechanical Engineering ( Undergraduate and Diploma ) , Electrical Engineering ( Undergraduate and Diploma ) , Industrial Engineering ( Undergraduate and Diploma ) , Informatics Engineering, Chemical Engineering ) Status: Quality Management System audit was conducted, No changes Exclusions: 7. Status of Organization and Employees

Any changes from previous audit? YES No

(Please detail the changes here)

Head Office Address No. of employees (FTE)

Jl. Bendungan Sigura Gura No.2, Malang , Jawa Timur, Indonesia 24

Additional locations covered by this report (Record site name, address, the number of employee and the period of the temporary/construction site in case where multiple site or construction/temporal site is applicable)

(^1) See notes.

Conclusion

It is recommended to EQA Head Office that the management system continues to meet, subject to corrective action, the requirements of EQA certification..

Transition to ISO9001: 2015 is not yet recommended..

A total of 0 major non conformities and 3 minor non conformities were raised during this visit. Full details are given within the body of this report

Based upon these findings a Corrective Action Plan is required.

Where required, the Corrective Action Plan must: ļ‚· Be submitted as a MS Word document. ļ‚· Reference your company name, the visit date and each nonconformity reference number, given in this report. ļ‚· Confirm the specific corrections made to address the issue (s) raised in the nonconformity and ensure the problem has been contained, together with the responsibilities and timescales for this (f it has not been completed already). ļ‚· Define the action plan to be taken that will identify and address the root cause(s) of the nonconformity, together with the responsibilities and timescales for completion.

The corrective action plan and its evidence must be submitted to EQA no later than 2 month.

It will be reviewed by your auditor for adequacy and EQA will confirm to you in writing the result of this review. The effectiveness of these actions will then be reviewed at your next planned visit..

ECF045-1b(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 4 |

meeting management review also. Top management (Dr. Ir. Lalu Mulyadi, MTA) has reviewed the

quality management system

 Evaluation on the level of management system integration (Only required in case where two or more management system are applicable)

ā—‹ The level of management system and its operation ļ‚Ÿ An integrated documentation set, including work instructions to a good level of development, as appropriate ( Y, N) ļ‚Ÿ Management Reviews that consider the overall business strategy and plan ( Y, N) ļ‚Ÿ An integrated approach to internal audits ( Y, N) ļ‚Ÿ An integrated approach to policy and objectives ( Y, N) ļ‚Ÿ An integrated approach to systems processes ( Y, N) ļ‚Ÿ An integrated approach to improvement mechanisms, (corrective and preventive action; measurement and continual Improvement) ( Y, N) ļ‚Ÿ Integrated management support and responsibilities ( Y, N)

ā—‹ Have auditors involved been qualified for each management system? Y, N

 Organizational context and complexity Organizational context that influences main stockholder, customers, status of subcontractor, whether or not it has foreign workers and complexity of production process is as below : the context of this higher education organization (national technology institute-Malang), is to provide and organize higher education in the field of engineering to meet market needs such as, community, higher education, private college coordination, and government. the hope of the community is to obtain higher education, so that they can get a job after this higher education, for the government also benefit and fulfilled, for example the availability of candidates with high education and sufficient competence so that productivity can be achieved. to meet all of ITN- Malang (this organization), has provided various resources to support this higher education process from curriculum planning, infrastructure provision, and quality assurance by internal team  Evaluation on compliance and effectiveness of management system Evaluation opinion on compliance and effectiveness of management system (including new management system in case of transition audit for new standard) application is as below : The complexity of operational processes has been designed and defined in the educational guidelines that refer to the 2014-2019 edition of the ITN-Malang educational manual, the outlines of strategies for educational implementation described in this manual, such as the design of curricula that have been adapted to national regulations on education ( has been done), scheduling / determining the educational calendar has also been fulfilled, as well as the implementation of teaching and learning activities and practicum has been implemented and still in the process and the exam must be done to determine the graduation of students have been designed, the entire operational process of the organization is in accordance with the system the quality management that has been executed, to monitor its achievement is done quality assurance of the internal audit team and the results reported as the evaluation material for management review

Personnel involved

The following personnel from your company were involved in this audit and or the opening and meeting: Name Job Title OM CM Dr. Ir. Lalu Mulyadi, MTA Rektor / Head of Institute Dr. Ir. Julianus Hutabarat,MT Wakil Rektor 1 / Deputy 1 Dr. Ir. Kustamar, MT Wakil Rektor 2 / Deputy 2 Ir. Daim Triwahyono, M.S.A Management Representative – LPM Head Ir. Subandiyah Aziz, CES Dean Ir. Hery Setyobudiarso, M.Sc Dean Endah Kusuma, Ssi,M.Kes Head of Administration Sibut, ST, MT Head of Program Ir. Yususf Ismail, MT Head of Program Ir. Harimbi Setyawati, MT Head of Program Kartika sari, ST Staff OM (^) Indicates if opening meeting attended, CM (^) if closing meeting attended.

The audit was conducted for EQA by:

ECF045-1b(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 5 |

Name Role Gugup Sunarko Lead Auditor Temter Ganda Pissa Auditor Rudy Wijaya Auditor

Audit Progamme

Three-year audit program (Annex 1) is to manage checking ā€˜core processes’, which should be checked at every audit, monitoring audit plan and implementation for ā€˜general management process’, which should be checked at least once per certification cycle, and checking ā€˜main quality/environmental/health & safety activities’ in terms of management system aspect. This 3-year audit program should be updated at every audit and provided for next term of audit for reference.

Follow up actions from the previous audit

Where applicable, the effectiveness of proposed corrective actions from nonconformities raised (NCR) at the previous audit has been reviewed and is detailed in the table below:

Nonconformities raised at this audit

The following nonconformities (NCR) and observations were raised at this visit, against your current standards.

Ref. No.

Category of NCR / Status

Details of nonconformity Follow up action reviewed by L.Auditor

Clause

  1. Minor / Open Several issues related to the controlling of QMS documentations such as the following thats against to requirements clause 4.2.
    • No complete record of change documents, registration and its distribution e.g. SOP/02/08/2013 – 20/2/2017 and some SOPs for Pasca Sarjana (no approval for realeased)
    • The code number as document ID did not match with defined standard of code e.g. SOP/Month/Sequence no/Year VS SOP/Unit code/Sequence no/Month/Year
      • SOP/02/01/

cl. 4.2.

  1. Minor / Open Several issues realted to the lessoning plan documents such as the following thats against to requirements clause 7.5.1.
    • In Pasca Sarjana (Prodi MI), The defined learnining objective for TI-312 didn’t match between syllabus and RPS
    • In Pasca Sarjana (Prodi MI), the lessoning subject T1213 (Analisa Risiko & Pengambilan Keputusan) was not fully match between RPS and lessoning report. Seem this subject was overlapping with subject of reasearch method / Metode Penelitian.
    • Several subject of lessoning were no documented RPS e.g. TI 322 (S2), TI 112 (S2), AR 4106, AR4111, SP 5124, PW 1201

cl. 7.5.

  1. Minor / Open (^) It was found the Elementery English Training at Lab Bahasa while the period of training April - July 2016 , where the participants have not been traced in the list of students, but the presence certificate is available, this is against to the clause of ISO 9001: 2008, section 8.2.3.

cl. 8.2.

Note: Closure at this stage is based upon proposed actions, which are subject to verification at the next visit.

ECF045-1b(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 7 |

  1. Major nonconformities will be raised where management standard requirements have been left out, were not implemented in practice or a number of minor nonconformities raised, which collectively indicate entire management system is not effective.
  2. Minor nonconformities will be raised where the management standard requirements have been addressed and implemented in general but there are minor gaps in meeting requirements or in their implementation.
  3. Any comments made in Auditor Notes should not be considered as consultancy or mandatory in any way.
  4. Where required, a Corrective Action Plan must be submitted by email no later than 30 days after the completion of the audit.
  5. If there are any significant details contained within this report that you do not agree with and would like amending, then please notify EQA of these within 30 days of the visit.
  6. First surveillance is typically due within 9 months of the initial audit. Annual surveillance is due at either 6 or 12 month intervals. Reassessments are generally scheduled 3 months before the certificate expiry and an agenda will be provided before the visit.
  7. An electronic copy of the report will be made available to the management representative at the end of the visit. Nonconformities are indexed with auditor initials and are sequential across a certification cycle.
  8. An electronic copy of this report (together with the appropriate completed checklist) will be submitted to the EQA office within one week of the visit. It will be maintained as a record of the visit by EQA and further copies are available upon request.
  9. Opening & Closing Meeting agenda shall follow that given in UK Auditor Manual
  10. Where the available audit evidence indicates that the audit objectives are unattainable or suggests the presence of an immediate and significant risk (e.g. safety), at the discretion of the Lead Auditor, the audit will be terminated.
  11. If you have any queries, please contact EQA by email at [email protected].
  12. Audit objectives are varied from audit types as below; 15-1) The generic surveillance audit objectives are the: Inquiry on your certification in terms of the relation with EQA a) Declaration on your system operation e.g. promotional brochure or website b) Request for Document and Records (via letter or electrical media) c) Methods to monitor your performances d) Internal audits and management review e) A review of actions taken on nonconformities identified during the previous audit f) Treatment of complaints g) Effectiveness of the management system with regard to achieving the certified client's objectives h) Progress of planned activities aimed at continual improvement i) Continuing operational control j) Review of any changes k) Use of marks and/or any other reference to certification 15-2) For stage 1 audits the objectives are; a) review the client’s management system documented information; b) evaluate the client’s site-specific conditions and to undertake discussions with the client’s personnel c) determine the preparedness for stage 2; d) iew the client’s status and understanding regarding requirements of the standard, in particular with respect to the identification of key performance or significant aspects, processes, objectives and operation of the management system; e) ain necessary information regarding the scope of the management system, f) iew the allocation of resources for stage 2 and agree the details of stage 2 g) ide a focus for planning stage 2 evaluate if the internal audits and management reviews are being planned and performed, and that the level of implementation of the management system substantiates that the client is ready for stage 2. 15.3) For stage 2 audits the objectives are: a) information and evidence about conformity to all requirements of the applicable management system standard or other normative documents; b) performance monitoring, measuring, reporting and reviewing against key performance objectives and targets (consistent with the expectations in the applicable management system standard or other normative document); c) the client’s management system ability and its performance regarding meeting of applicable statutory, regulatory and contractual requirements; d) operational control of the client’s processes; e) internal auditing and management review; f) management responsibility for the client’s policies. 15.4) For recertification audits the objectives are; a) To confirm the continued conformity and effectiveness of the management system b) To confirm its continued relevance and applicability for the scope of certification c) The effectiveness of the management system in its entirety in the light of internal and external changes and its continued relevance and applicability to the certification. d) Demonstrated commitment to maintain the effectiveness and improvement of the management system in order to enhance overall performance e) The effectiveness of the management system with regard to achieving the certified client’s objectives and the intended results of the respective management system

Annex 1. 3-year audit program

ECF045-1b(May/01/2016)Edition 7 Rev.2 EQA 8 |

3 - Year Audit Program Explanatory notes

P : Plan A : Action

Audit Stage Stage 1 Stage 2 Surv. 1 Surv. 2 Re- Certificate

Multisite(s) NA NA NA NA NA

Visit duration(MD) 1 2 1 1 2

Main aspects and activities

Main Quality/Environmental/H&S aspects and activities

Planning Curriculum Plan A A P P Survey to student A A P P Regulation A A P P Trial of curriculums A A P P Processing Learning Processes A A P Presentation A A P Practicum A A P Examination A A P checking Monitoring report A A P^ P Customer Survey A A P P Graduate monitoring A A P^ P

Journal System A A P^ P Decisions Processes Review A A P Instrument System A A P New Targets A A P

Must-check process(es)

Items to be checked at every visit

Internal Audit A A A P P

Management Review A A A P P Quality policy, quality goal and quality goal achievement plan

A A A P P

Legal Compliance A A A P P

Infrastructure A A A P P

Nonconformities and corrective actions

A A A P P

Design and development program

A A A P P

General Management Processes

Understanding of organization and organizational situation

A A A P

Communication A A A P

Documented information A A A P Support A A P Appropriateness A P P

Customer satisfaction/Customer importance

A A P P

Nonconformity output/Product control A A A P