Bergson's Philosophy: Understanding Life, Consciousness, and Vital Impetus, Summaries of Philosophy

Henri bergson's philosophy revolves around the concept of 'creative evolution,' which explores the nature of life, consciousness, and the vital impetus. Bergson critiques traditional notions of mechanism and teleology, introducing the concept of transformism to explain the evolutionary process. His philosophy integrates science and metaphysics, emphasizing the importance of intuition in discerning true problems. Bergson's critique of false problems, the role of duration and memory, and the method of intersection to solve problems related to soul and body, matter and spirit.

Typology: Summaries

2022/2023

Uploaded on 01/18/2024

teacher-lauren
teacher-lauren 🇧🇪

1 document

1 / 7

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
Bergson creates his argument in response to the complex nature of existence and how it involves a constant
passage from one state to another. He explores the process of ageing and the impetus for growth and
development. The idea of life is presented as a visible current passing through organisms, dividing among
species and individuals without losing its force.
The text also discusses transformism, the concept of mechanism and duration, and the limitations of
current understanding in science. It highlights the importance of duration in human consciousness and
experience, acknowledging that the whole universe might be an indivisible continuity, and the systems
isolated by science are partial views of the whole.
The philosophy of Bergson is based on key stages such as Duration, Memory, and Elan Vital. The method of
Bergsonism is Intuition, which is not merely a feeling, but a fully developed philosophical method. Intuition
relies on duration, which Bergson raised to the level of a philosophical method. Precision in philosophy is
achieved through intuition, as it involves strict rules according to Bergson. To establish philosophy as a
precise discipline comparable to science, Bergson relied on the intuitive method.
The rules of Bergson's intuitive method consist of three distinct acts: stating and creating problems,
discovering genuine differences, and apprehending real-time. The first rule is to apply the test of true and
false to the problems themselves. False problems must be condemned, and truth and creation must be
reconciled at the problem level.
True and false are not limited to solutions; society and education impose ready-made problems. True
freedom lies in the power to decide and constitute problems, involving the disappearance of false problems
and the creative upsurge of true ones. In philosophy, finding and stating the problem is as crucial as solving
it, as invention is involved in both.
The history of humanity is the construction of problems, and becoming aware of this activity is like the
conquest of freedom. The problem has a constitutive power residing in it, and humanity makes its own
history through the construction of problems. Bergson attempts an intrinsic determination of the false in
the expression "false problem," providing a complementary rule to the general rule to reconcile with the
norm of the true.
In his philosophy, Bergson critiques the negative and negation as sources of false problems. False problems
are categorized into two types: non-existent problems and badly stated questions. Non-existent problems
arise due to confusion between "more" and "less." Disorder, non-being, and the possible are examples of
non-existent problems, which are more than the corresponding being, order, and real. On the other hand,
badly stated questions involve composite terms that arbitrarily group things differing in kind, such as the
problem of happiness reducible to pleasure and the problem of intensity.
Bergson argues that the problem of intensity is a badly stated question involving a mixture of
determinations differing in kind. Bergson criticizes the obsession with thinking in terms of more and less in
pf3
pf4
pf5

Partial preview of the text

Download Bergson's Philosophy: Understanding Life, Consciousness, and Vital Impetus and more Summaries Philosophy in PDF only on Docsity!

Bergson creates his argument in response to the complex nature of existence and how it involves a constant passage from one state to another. He explores the process of ageing and the impetus for growth and development. The idea of life is presented as a visible current passing through organisms, dividing among species and individuals without losing its force. The text also discusses transformism, the concept of mechanism and duration, and the limitations of current understanding in science. It highlights the importance of duration in human consciousness and experience, acknowledging that the whole universe might be an indivisible continuity, and the systems isolated by science are partial views of the whole. The philosophy of Bergson is based on key stages such as Duration, Memory, and Elan Vital. The method of Bergsonism is Intuition, which is not merely a feeling, but a fully developed philosophical method. Intuition relies on duration, which Bergson raised to the level of a philosophical method. Precision in philosophy is achieved through intuition, as it involves strict rules according to Bergson. To establish philosophy as a precise discipline comparable to science, Bergson relied on the intuitive method. The rules of Bergson's intuitive method consist of three distinct acts: stating and creating problems, discovering genuine differences, and apprehending real-time. The first rule is to apply the test of true and false to the problems themselves. False problems must be condemned, and truth and creation must be reconciled at the problem level. True and false are not limited to solutions; society and education impose ready-made problems. True freedom lies in the power to decide and constitute problems, involving the disappearance of false problems and the creative upsurge of true ones. In philosophy, finding and stating the problem is as crucial as solving it, as invention is involved in both. The history of humanity is the construction of problems, and becoming aware of this activity is like the conquest of freedom. The problem has a constitutive power residing in it, and humanity makes its own history through the construction of problems. Bergson attempts an intrinsic determination of the false in the expression "false problem," providing a complementary rule to the general rule to reconcile with the norm of the true. In his philosophy, Bergson critiques the negative and negation as sources of false problems. False problems are categorized into two types: non-existent problems and badly stated questions. Non-existent problems arise due to confusion between "more" and "less." Disorder, non-being, and the possible are examples of non-existent problems, which are more than the corresponding being, order, and real. On the other hand, badly stated questions involve composite terms that arbitrarily group things differing in kind, such as the problem of happiness reducible to pleasure and the problem of intensity. Bergson argues that the problem of intensity is a badly stated question involving a mixture of determinations differing in kind. Bergson criticizes the obsession with thinking in terms of more and less in

non-existent problems and argues that disorder arises when irreducible orders are reduced to a general idea of order. He believes that non-being arises when different realities are muddled into a homogeneous Being opposed to nothingness, and the idea of the possible emerges when all existence is related to a preformed element. Bergson borrows from Kant the idea that reason engenders inevitable illusions, deeply rooted in the intelligence. He emphasizes that intuition can activate the critical tendency in intelligence, distinguishing between true and false problems. Intelligence states problems, but intuition guides intelligence in discerning true and false problems by rediscovering differences in kind. Ultimately, intuition drives intelligence to turn back against itself in the quest for truth. The second rule described in the text emphasizes on the struggle against illusion and the rediscovery of true differences in kind or articulations of the real. According to Bergson, a composite needs division according to its natural articulations into elements that differ in kind. Intuition as a method involves a Platonic- inspired division. Bergson's method involves both broadening and narrowing, and philosophy aims to open us to the inhuman and superhuman, transcending the human condition. Going beyond experience does not involve concepts but real experience in all its peculiarities. The complementary rule states that the real involves both cutting along natural articulations and intersecting again towards a virtual point. The method of intersection is applied to solve problems related to soul and body, matter and spirit, by showing how lines of objectivity and subjectivity must converge. The convergence of lines defines a superior probabilism, capable of solving problems and bringing conditions back to the conditioned, eliminating any remaining distance between them. The third rule of Bergsonism states that problems should be stated and solved in terms of time rather than space. According to this rule, intuition presupposes and consists of thinking in terms of duration, which involves the movement of division determining differences in kind. The primary division in Bergsonism is between duration and space, with all other dualisms derived from or related to it. Duration has the power to bear differences in kind, while space only presents differences of degree. Intuition becomes a method, reconciling itself with the immediate and allowing perception of durations differing in kind. Bergson's evolution involves duration becoming less reducible to psychological experience and more a variable essence of things.

  • Objective of Creative Evolution
    • Grasping "the true nature" of life and the profound meaning of the evolutionary process.
  • Living Body and Duration
    • Bergson challenges traditional notions in the first chapter of Creative Evolution.
    • Living body: More than a mere assemblage of parts; exhibits organic unity and continuity through time.
  • Aging as Transformation and "Creation"
    • Aging is a continuous process, akin to embryonic development.
    • Bergson's concept of "creation" in aging: not fabrication but transformation, a becoming-other of the organism.
  • Bergson's Critique of Mechanism and Vitalism
    • Bergson rejects mechanistic reductionism and vitalism.
    • Argues for departing from Cartesian mechanism and teleology to understand life.
  • Bergson's Opposition to Vitalism
    • Vitalism posits a "vital principle" guiding organism development.
    • Bergson opposes vitalism, asserting the need to depart from physico-chemistry to comprehend life.
  • Conclusion of the Passage
    • Bergson's philosophy involves breaking with traditional frameworks.
    • Duration and real evolution are pivotal, challenging deterministic and teleological perspectives. Evolution and Vital Impetus: Bergson's Perspective
  • Inadequacy of Mechanism and Teleology
    • Mechanism and teleology fail to explain the evolutionary process in living beings and organized bodies.
    • Bergson introduces the concept of "transformism," exploring continuous transformations leading to new species and individuals.
  • Evolutionary Theories: Transformism and Paradigm
    • Lamarck's idea of transformism gains prominence in understanding the temporal order in natural history.
    • Transformism, or the theory of evolution, remains a hypothesis but has increasing probability.
    • Evolutionism becomes a paradigm in biological sciences.
  • Bergson's Challenge to Mechanism and Radical Teleology
    • Bergson rejects mechanistic and teleological views in philosophy.
    • Challenges arise through crucial experiences, especially in understanding the evolution of the eye.
    • Mechanistic theories fail when explaining the direction of evolution, while teleological views reintroduce a final cause.
  • Partial Views of Evolution
    • Scientific hypotheses on evolution offer partial views.
    • Philosophy, at the intersection of scientific facts, must disengage ideas about life suggested by these hypotheses.
  • The Image of the Vital Impetus
    • Bergson's chosen image is the "vital impetus."
    • Life as a "current" flowing from an original impulse, branching into diverse evolutionary lines.
    • Rejects radical teleology but acknowledges the need for a non-arbitrary philosophy of life.
  • Integration of Scientific Hypotheses
    • Bergson incorporates elements from scientific hypotheses: tendency toward internal change, direction in variations, and non-subjective causality.
    • The vital impetus represents unpredictable, continual creation of forms.
  • Vital Impetus as Stream of Consciousness
    • The vital impetus aligns with the stream of consciousness.
    • Characteristics include unpredictable development, continuous change, qualitative transformation, and irreversible becoming.
    • Choices in impetus represent intentions or virtualities realized without the need for a goal.
  • Organization in Life and Materiality
  • Virtualities, not predetermined, drive evolution. Evolution advances through actualization of virtualities, not duplication.
  • Life's Status: No General Concept or Principle
  • Life is not a general concept grouping all living beings.
  • Life is a "tendency to act on brute matter," and its action is not predetermined.
  • Life's historicity appears in thinking "in duration," revealing the totality opened by history.
  • Intelligence and Intuition
  • Bergson critiques intelligence, noting its limits in dealing with organic and spiritual life.
  • Intelligence is a faculty for fabricating unorganized instruments.
  • Intelligence's spatialized knowledge is indifferent to duration, novelty, and radical becoming.
  • Bergson introduces "intuition" as a comprehensive movement that reunites the mind with the impetus of life.
  • Intuition is an active hold on duration and expands to matter, breaking with traditional metaphysics.
  • Philosophical Act and Intuition's Significance
  • Intuition gives life its profound significance, integrating various dimensions of organic, psychic, and social life.
  • The philosophical act is the continuation or integration of multiple experiences of life.
  • Intuition thrusts us into consciousness in general, sympathizing not only with other consciousnesses but also with the vital in all living beings.
  • Fundamental cause of organization is grasped through consciousness, recapturing the impetus of life within us.
  • Experience of Life and Metaphysics
  • Intense experiences of life, breaking intellectual frameworks, reconnect us with creative duration.
  • Duration is the crossroads of all problems in Bergson's metaphysics, and its scope and meaning are grasped from our experience of living beings.