Equal Rights vs. Fourteenth Amendment: A Comparison, Assignments of Nursing

A discussion prompt for a political science course, focusing on the comparison between the equal rights amendment and the fourteenth amendment. It explores the distinct concepts addressed by each amendment, their historical context, and their impact on american society. The document also includes student responses that provide insights into their understanding of the topic.

Typology: Assignments

2023/2024

Available from 12/13/2024

Milestonee
Milestonee 🇺🇸

4.2

(33)

4.3K documents

1 / 2

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
POLI 330N Week 7 Discussion
Option 1: The Equal Rights Amendment was first proposed almost a century ago and has
still not been added to the United States Constitution. It is supposed to guarantee equal legal
rights for all American citizens regardless of sex. It was first introduced to Congress by Alice
Paul, leader of women's suffrage movement in 1923. Compare/contrast the Equal Rights
Amendment with the Fourteenth Amendment. Did they deal with separate concepts? Explain
your answer.
Option 2: The Bill of Rights is not only included with the United States Constitution but also
state constitutions. All states have provisions in their constitutions that protect individual
rights. Go online and look up your state constitution concerning amendments that are
included in the Bill of Rights. How does your state constitution protect your individual
rights?
Answer
The Equal Rights Amendment was a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution that
would provide legal rights to all Americans, regardless of gender, while the Fourteenth
Amendment promised equal protection of the laws to all Americans, including formerly enslaved
people (Voros, 2017, p.13). The Equal Rights Amendment said that women should have equal
rights in the United States without being discriminated against because of their gender. In
contrast, the Fourteenth Amendment encouraged citizenship to all people born in the United
States, including freed slaves (Brown et al, 1971. P. 881). Both amendments were intended to
protect the United States citizens, and they all advocated for social justice. They ensured a place
pf2

Partial preview of the text

Download Equal Rights vs. Fourteenth Amendment: A Comparison and more Assignments Nursing in PDF only on Docsity!

POLI 330N Week 7 DiscussionOption 1: The Equal Rights Amendment was first proposed almost a century ago and has still not been added to the United States Constitution. It is supposed to guarantee equal legal rights for all American citizens regardless of sex. It was first introduced to Congress by Alice Paul, leader of women's suffrage movement in 1923. Compare/contrast the Equal Rights Amendment with the Fourteenth Amendment. Did they deal with separate concepts? Explain your answer.  Option 2: The Bill of Rights is not only included with the United States Constitution but also state constitutions. All states have provisions in their constitutions that protect individual rights. Go online and look up your state constitution concerning amendments that are included in the Bill of Rights. How does your state constitution protect your individual rights? Answer The Equal Rights Amendment was a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution that would provide legal rights to all Americans, regardless of gender, while the Fourteenth Amendment promised equal protection of the laws to all Americans, including formerly enslaved people (Voros, 2017, p.13). The Equal Rights Amendment said that women should have equal rights in the United States without being discriminated against because of their gender. In contrast, the Fourteenth Amendment encouraged citizenship to all people born in the United States, including freed slaves (Brown et al, 1971. P. 881). Both amendments were intended to protect the United States citizens, and they all advocated for social justice. They ensured a place

for women in society and educated the public on the importance of gender balance. The amendments were intended to harmonize the legal system of the United States of America. The Fourteenth Amendment prohibited anyone who had gone to war against a given country from holding any state or federal office (Stein & Bauer, 1995, p.127). However, the Equal Rights Amendment focused primarily on women being granted a level playing field in elective positions to attain gender parity. References Brown,B.A.,Emerson,T.I.,Falk,G.,&Freedman,A.E.(1971).Theequalrights amendment:Aconstitutionalbasisforequalrightsforwomen.TheYaleLawJournal, 80(5),871-985. Voros,F.(2017).Understandingthe14thAmendment.UtahBarJournal,30(3),10-15. Stein,D.,&Bauer,J.(1995).Interpretingthe14thAmendment:Automaticcitizenshipfor childrenofilegalimmigrants.Stan.L.&Pol'yRev.,7,127. Response 1 – posted 6/ Yes, I agree that the two Amendments had distinct concepts. The Equal Rights Amendment, fore xample, is more concerned with promoting women's rights, but the 14th Amendment is concerned with the equal protection of all Americans, regardles of sex or gender. Response 2 Furthermore, the Equal Rights Amendment examined the political and scape to see if women's suffrage was apoint of debate. The 14th^ Amendment, on the other hand, examines the rights to life, liberty, and property ownership – more over, the importance of ensuring that everyone receives due proces and equal protection.