Ideal Government: Liberty vs. Collective Authority - Conservatives, Liberals & Modern Thin, Exercises of Culture & Society

A series of questions to consider regarding the ideal form of government and the tension between individual liberty and collective authority. The questions explore the perspectives of classical conservatives (aristotle), classical liberals (locke and rousseau), and modern philosophers such as tocqueville and mill. The document also asks about the appropriate limits to individual liberty and collective authority, and the relevance of these concerns in today's context.

Typology: Exercises

2012/2013

Uploaded on 01/08/2013

dhansukh
dhansukh 🇮🇳

5

(2)

33 documents

1 / 1

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
Questions to Consider
What is the ideal form of government?
- for classical conservatives (Aristotle)?
- for classical liberals (Locke and Rousseau)?
- for “modern” philosophers
- Tocqueville?
- Mill?
Is there a tension between individual liberty and collective authority?
- What does Mill say?
- Consider this in context of
- what classics say
- Mill’s life and times
- What do you think?
What are the appropriate limits to collective authority and individual liberty?
- according to Mill
- classics/contemporaries
- your opinion
Do these concerns have any relevance today?
Do these concerns touch upon topics that are of interest to you?
Is this book/are these concerns relevant to the study of classical sociological theory?
- Does Mill ask sociological questions?
- Does he provide a sociological theory?
[Here we might want to consider what sociology is, when philosophers become
sociologists, and why we read Marx, Durkheim, and Weber, instead of Machiavelli,
More, and Mill, or, for that matter, Spencer, Pareto, and Tonnies.]
Docsity.com

Partial preview of the text

Download Ideal Government: Liberty vs. Collective Authority - Conservatives, Liberals & Modern Thin and more Exercises Culture & Society in PDF only on Docsity!

Questions to Consider

What is the ideal form of government?

  • for classical conservatives (Aristotle)?
  • for classical liberals (Locke and Rousseau)?
  • for “modern” philosophers
    • Tocqueville?
    • Mill?

Is there a tension between individual liberty and collective authority?

  • What does Mill say?
  • Consider this in context of
    • what classics say
    • Mill’s life and times
  • What do you think?

What are the appropriate limits to collective authority and individual liberty?

  • according to Mill
  • classics/contemporaries
  • your opinion

Do these concerns have any relevance today?

Do these concerns touch upon topics that are of interest to you?

Is this book/are these concerns relevant to the study of classical sociological theory?

  • Does Mill ask sociological questions?
  • Does he provide a sociological theory?

[Here we might want to consider what sociology is, when philosophers become sociologists, and why we read Marx, Durkheim, and Weber, instead of Machiavelli, More, and Mill, or, for that matter, Spencer, Pareto, and Tonnies.]

Docsity.com