Team # ____________________
Proposal Evaluation Sheet
Introduction: 5 points
Max Score
Min Score
Problem
(1) โ Clearly defined problem statement and
justification of problem
(0) โ Problem statement unclear or
justification missing
Solution, Visual Aid
(1) โ Concise description of solution and
how it will solve the problem. Visual aid
shows how solution is used in context
(0) โ Unclear description of solution or
visual aid lacking detail
High-level Requirements
(3) โ Three clear, comprehensive,
and quantitative (where applicable)
reqs.
(1) โ one requirement
unclear or missing
(0) โ more than
one requirement
unclear or missing
Design: 13 points
Max Score
Min Score
Block Diagram
(+ mechanical drawings, if
applicable)
(3) โ complete and detailed, labelling
supply voltages, data protocols, with
logically separated subsystems
(1) โ lacking important
detail, or missing
components
(0) โ lacking
multiple important
details or missing
subsystems
Subsystem Overview
(4) โ description of purpose of
subsystems and their components,
including interaction with other
subsystems
(2) โ one subsystem
description lacking
important details
(0) โ multiple
subsystems
unclear or lacking
detail
Subsystem Requirements
(3) โ comprehensive list of reqs that
are qualitative and testable. Should not
include specifications for off-the-shelf
components. See R&V page on site.
(2) โ missing one req
necessary for subsystem
function or includes
component specs
(0) โ most
subsystem reqs
incomplete or
inappropriate
Tolerance Analysis
(3) โfeasibility of a critical subsystem
function proven through mathematical
analysis or simulation
(1) โanalysis unsound
or fails to demonstrate
feasibility of subsystem
(0) โmissing
tolerance analysis
Ethics & Safety: 3 points
Max Score
Min Score
Considers all ethical issues
specific to project
Explains how the project and
design process address these
ethical issues
References appropriate ethics
code (no plagiarism)
Considers all safety issues
specific to project
References any relevant safety
or regulatory standards
(3) โ includes all
elements
(2) โ one incomplete or
missing element
(0) โ three or more missing
elements
