Docsity
Docsity

Prepara tus exámenes
Prepara tus exámenes

Prepara tus exámenes y mejora tus resultados gracias a la gran cantidad de recursos disponibles en Docsity


Consigue puntos base para descargar
Consigue puntos base para descargar

Gana puntos ayudando a otros estudiantes o consíguelos activando un Plan Premium


Orientación Universidad
Orientación Universidad


Critical authors unit1, Apuntes de Filología hispánica

Critical authors unit1

Tipo: Apuntes

2015/2016

Subido el 07/09/2016

pedrolmo
pedrolmo 🇪🇸

4.3

(76)

104 documentos

1 / 4

Toggle sidebar

Esta página no es visible en la vista previa

¡No te pierdas las partes importantes!

bg1
ROLAND BARTHES (1915-1968). Extract from “The Death of the Author” (1968)
Summary of the text:
The figure of the author is recent and appeared along with the discover of the
prestige of the individual. Therefore, this capitalist society has attached the greatest
important in literature to the person of the author. Literature is, then, tyrannically centred
on the author, whilst criticism consist in saying that one's work is the result of one's life. It
is, therefore, the allegory of the writer's life. Nevertheless, in Mallarmé's poetics the author
is suppressed in interest of the writing and Valéry never stop deriding the Author claiming
for the essentially verbal condition of literature.
The author was thought to nourish the book, the before. The modern scriptor is born
with the text, not preceding or exceeding it.
A text is not a message of the Author-God, theological meaning, but a variety of
writings blending and clashing. To give a text an author is to impose a limit on that text, but
texts refuse an ultimate meaning, liberate themselves from godlike authors. The birth of
the reader must be at the cost of the death of the author
Definitions:
- Author: Poststructuralist criticism challenges the category of the author as omniscient or
the single source of power in relation to a text, as an authority; meaning is not limited to,
fixed by or located in the person of the author.
- Sign: Swiss linguist Ferdinand Saussure noted that every sign (a basic unit of
communication such as a letter or a word) is made up of two components: the signifier (the
materially identifiable element such as a sound or a visible mark) and the signified (the
conceptual referent of the sign). Saussure argued that the relationship between signifier
and signified is not stable but arbitrary and based on social convention: English speakers
“agree” that the word/signifier horse refers to a certain signified: a type of four-footed
animal with hooves, a tail and a mane and which may be ridden by humans or used as a
beast of burden. However, for Spanish speakers, the signifier for this particular
referent/signified is caballo. The division of the sign, as well as its arbitrary relation to
reality, is central to twentieth century theory of language and literature.
pf3
pf4

Vista previa parcial del texto

¡Descarga Critical authors unit1 y más Apuntes en PDF de Filología hispánica solo en Docsity!

ROLAND BARTHES (1915-1968). Extract from “The Death of the Author” (1968) Summary of the text: The figure of the author is recent and appeared along with the discover of the prestige of the individual. Therefore, this capitalist society has attached the greatest important in literature to the person of the author. Literature is, then, tyrannically centred on the author, whilst criticism consist in saying that one's work is the result of one's life. It is, therefore, the allegory of the writer's life. Nevertheless, in Mallarmé's poetics the author is suppressed in interest of the writing and Valéry never stop deriding the Author claiming for the essentially verbal condition of literature. The author was thought to nourish the book, the before. The modern scriptor is born with the text, not preceding or exceeding it. A text is not a message of the Author-God, theological meaning, but a variety of writings blending and clashing. To give a text an author is to impose a limit on that text, but texts refuse an ultimate meaning, liberate themselves from godlike authors. The birth of the reader must be at the cost of the death of the author Definitions:

- Author: Poststructuralist criticism challenges the category of the author as omniscient or the single source of power in relation to a text, as an authority; meaning is not limited to, fixed by or located in the person of the author. - Sign: Swiss linguist Ferdinand Saussure noted that every sign (a basic unit of communication such as a letter or a word) is made up of two components: the signifier (the materially identifiable element such as a sound or a visible mark) and the signified (the conceptual referent of the sign). Saussure argued that the relationship between signifier and signified is not stable but arbitrary and based on social convention: English speakers “agree” that the word/signifier horse refers to a certain signified: a type of four-footed animal with hooves, a tail and a mane and which may be ridden by humans or used as a beast of burden. However, for Spanish speakers, the signifier for this particular referent/signified is caballo. The division of the sign, as well as its arbitrary relation to reality, is central to twentieth century theory of language and literature.

- Death of the author: From Roland Barthes's essay of the same title, the phrase has come to mean the resistance to using information derived from the writer's life or known intention as part of the process of interpretation since this presumes that the author imposes the final limit on meaning and attributed to him (or her) a godlike status. - Lisible / Scriptible: Used by Roland Barthes in the definition of types of text, the terms are translatable as “readerly” and “writerly”... the readerly text does all the wok for the reader, leaving the reader in the role of passive consumer. The writerly text makes the reader work and resist the convention of readerly or realist textuality, principally the assumption of linguistic transparency and the self-evidence of meaning. JACQUES DERRIDA (1930-2004) From “Of Grammatology” (1967) Summary of the text: The writer writes in a language and in a logic which his discourse cannot dominate absolutely. So the reading must always aim at a certain relationship, unperceived by the writer, between what he commands and what he does not command of the patterns of the language that he uses. That is what critical reading should produce. To produce cannot consist of reproducing. Yet if reading must not be content with doubling the text, it cannot legitimately transgress the text toward something other than itself, toward a referent or a signified outside the text. Therefore, Derrida proposes the absence of the referent or the transcendental signified = There is nothing outside of the text (il n'ya pas de hors-texte). It seems quite impossible to separate the signifier from the signified, but we must take into account the history of the text in general. When we think about the writer and the encompassing power of the language, we are not just thinking about literature, but about philosophy, chronicles... every writing. Literary writing has, almost always and almost everywhere, lent itself to this transcendent reading, in that search for the signified which we here put in question, not to annul it but to understand it within a system to which such a reading is blind.

critical difference from itself.

  • Binary oppositions: “the principle of contrast between two mutually exclusive terms: on/off, up/down, left/right” (Baldick). Poststructuralists (especially Derrida) seek to destabilise these oppositions (sometimes referred to in deconstruction as violent hierarchies ) and foreground the second term. Poststructuralists also argue that each term of the binary is dependent on the other in order to constitute itself. - Différance: Neologism coined by Jacques Derrida. The difference between difference and difference is inaudible. Whatever might be called the meaning or identity of difference, therefore, exists only within writing, which is to say also that it exists only as writing... difference marks the opening of a system of differences... Everything differs, which is to say that everything defers. A thing differs because it “is” cannot be what anything else is, but also because what it is has to do with the fact that it differs from other things. To say that something is it to say that it differs. It is also to say at the same time that, in so far as it differs, it defers endlessly its “own” constitution as an autonomous or fully complete entity, whether as sign, truth, subject or the lide. Difference, then, names this work of differing and deferring that makes differences possible. - Phonocentrism: According to Derrida, phonocentrism depens on the association of truth with the logos as the philosophical and theological origin of truth understood as self- revealing thought or cosmic reason... phonocentrism is the powerful idea that there is difference between spoken words and written signs, with all the privilege being on the side of the former.